Empedocles - Pre-Socratics - Ancient Philosophy
History of Western Philosophy - 2024 Inhalt

Ancient Philosophy

Pre-Socratics

Empedocles

The archetype of the philosopher-prophet, scientist, and charlatan, a figure previously exemplified by Pythagoras, finds its fullest expression in Empedocles, whose active life roughly coincided with 440 BCE. Though a younger contemporary of Parmenides, his teachings in certain respects bear a closer resemblance to those of Heraclitus. A citizen of Akragas on the southern coast of Sicily, Empedocles was a democratic political figure who simultaneously claimed a divine status. Throughout the Greek cities, particularly in Sicily, the constant conflict between democracy and tyranny meant that leaders of both factions often faced execution or exile. Exiles felt little compunction about negotiating with Greece’s enemies, Persia in the East and Carthage in the West. Empedocles also experienced exile, yet he seems to have chosen the path of a saint rather than that of a scheming outcast. Perhaps influenced by Orphism in his youth, he initially combined political engagement with scientific inquiry, only to adopt the role of a prophet in the twilight of his life.

Numerous legends surrounded Empedocles. It was believed that he performed miracles, sometimes through magic and at others through scientific knowledge that appeared miraculous to the uninitiated. He was said to command the winds and to have revived a woman who had appeared dead for thirty days. Ultimately, he purportedly met his end by leaping into the crater of Mount Etna to prove his divinity. As the poet puts it:

Great Empedocles, with a fiery soul,
Leapt into Etna and was wholly scorched.

Matthew Arnold penned a poem on this theme, though despite its reputation as one of his less successful works, it does not include the aforementioned couplet.

Like Parmenides, Empedocles composed his thoughts in verse. Lucretius, influenced by his work, esteemed Empedocles as a poet, though opinions on his literary merit have always been divided. Because only fragments of his writings survive, any definitive judgment of his poetic quality remains elusive.

It is essential to consider the science and religion of Empedocles separately, as they do not form a coherent system. I shall first examine his scientific contributions, then his cosmology, and finally his religious beliefs.

Scientific Discoveries and Observations

The most significant contribution of Empedocles to science was his discovery of air as a distinct substance. He demonstrated this through observation: when a bucket or similar vessel is inverted in water, the liquid is prevented from entering. Empedocles states:

Empedocles illustrates his principles through the image of a girl playing with a gleaming bronze clepsydra.

When she seals the tube’s opening with her hand and dips it into the silvery water, no liquid enters the vessel.


The water is held back by the mass of air pressing from within against the tiny holes.


Only when she uncovers the opening and allows the air to escape does the proper measure of water flow in.

This excerpt appears in his explanation of the nature of respiration. Empedocles also identified at least one instance of centrifugal force: when a bowl of water is spun at the end of a rope, the water remains inside.

He recognized that plants have sexes and formulated a rudimentary theory of evolution and the survival of the fittest. Initially:

From their mingling emerged
Myriad tribes of mortal beings,
Endowed with every kind of form—
A marvel to behold!
There were heads without ears, hands without shoulders,
Eyes without foreheads, dismembered limbs striving to unite.
All these were haphazardly connected;
There were clumsy creatures with countless hands,
Beings with faces and chests turned in different directions,
Creatures with the body of a bull and the face of a man,
And others with the body of a man and the snout of a bull.
There were hermaphrodites, combining male and female natures,
Yet barren. In the end, only certain forms survived.

Regarding astronomy, he understood that the Moon shines with reflected light and believed the same to be true for the Sun. He asserted that light requires a specific amount of time to travel, though this interval is so brief that it escapes human notice. He also recognized that a solar eclipse occurs when the Moon passes between the Sun and the Earth, a fact he likely learned from Anaxagoras.

He was the founder of the Italian school of medicine, which began with him and subsequently influenced Plato and Aristotle. According to Barnett, this school shaped the entire trajectory of scientific and philosophical thought.

All this attests to a scientific vigor that had no equal in the later centuries of Greek history.

Cosmology of Elements and Forces

I now turn to his cosmology. As previously mentioned, Empedocles regarded earth, fire, air, and water as the four elements, though he did not use that specific term. Each of these elements is eternal, yet they intermingle in various proportions to produce the mutable, complex substances found in the world. These elements are united by Love and divided by Strife. For Empedocles, Love and Strife are primary substances, just as earth, air, fire, and water are. At certain times, Love prevails, while at others, Strife dominates. There once existed a Golden Age when Love reigned supreme, during which humanity worshipped only the Cyprian Aphrodite. Changes in the world are not dictated by purpose but occur solely by Chance and Necessity. Development proceeds in a cyclical manner: when the elements are fully blended by Love, Strife gradually separates them; when Strife divides them, Love begins to unite them once more. Thus, every complex substance is transient, while the elements, along with Strife and Love, remain eternal.

This notion resembles that of Heraclitus, though in a more tempered form, as it is not merely Strife but the interplay of both Strife and Love that engenders change. Plato connects Heraclitus with Empedocles in the Sophist:

“Later, some Ionian and Sicilian Muses reasoned that it is safest to unite both perspectives, asserting that being is both multiple and one, and that it is held together by enmity and friendship. ’What diverges always converges,’ say the stricter among the Muses; while the more accommodating have always allowed that all things take turns being unified and beloved by Aphrodite, and then multiple and hostile to themselves due to some discord.”

Empedocles asserted that the material world is spherical. During the Golden Age, Strife was external while Love was internal. Gradually, however, Strife infiltrated the world, banishing Love until, in the darkest times, Love resides entirely outside the sphere and Strife dwells wholly within it. Then, though the cause remains unclear, a contrary movement begins. This restores the Golden Age—if only temporarily—before the entire cycle repeats. One might imagine that each stage could be stable, yet this was not the perspective of Empedocles. He sought to explain movement while acknowledging the arguments of Parmenides, yet he resisted the conclusion that the universe must be immutable at any stage.

Religious Views and Pythagorean Influence

The religious views of Empedocles were primarily Pythagorean. In a fragment that likely refers to Pythagoras, he states:

There was among them a certain man, possessing extraordinary knowledge,
Who garnered the greatest wealth of intellect,
And was particularly skilled in various wise endeavors.
As soon as he directed his mind with all his might,
He easily perceived each of all existing things,
Both across ten and twenty human centuries.

In the Golden Age, as previously noted, people worshipped only Aphrodite.

Yet the altar was not sprinkled with pure blood,
But this was the greatest abomination among men:
Ripping life apart, they devoured noble limbs.

On one occasion, he spoke of himself in florid terms, as a god:

Friends! You who dwell in the grand city on the shores
Of golden Akragas,
On the very acropolis, caring for noble deeds,
You are esteemed havens for strangers,
Unacquainted with harm.
Greetings to you! And I am no longer a man, but an immortal god
For you—
I stride, revered by all as is proper,
Wreathed in ribbons and verdant garlands:
Hardly do I arrive in blossoming cities—
Men and women honor me. They follow me—
Hordes and hordes—seeking to learn where the path to benefit lies:
Some desire prophecies, others inquire about various ailments,
Hoping to hear a healing word,
Long tormented by grievous sufferings.
Yes, why do I emphasize this? As if I were doing something significant,
If I surpass mortals, perishing from the multitude
Of human calamities.

Sin, Reincarnation, and the Path to Divinity

At another time, he perceives himself as a great sinner, atoning for his wickedness:
There is an oracle of Necessity (Ananke),
An ancient decree of the gods,
Eternal, bound by oaths as if sealed by a stamp:
If any demon (deity) defiles his members
With blood (through murder) due to transgression,
And following Hatred, swears a guilty oath—
Among those destined for a long life—
He must wander for thirty thousand years far from the blessed,
Reborn over time in various forms
Of mortal beings,
Changing the agonizing paths of life.
The might of the Ether drives him into the Sea,
The Sea spits him onto the soil of the Earth, the Earth—toward the rays
Of the Radiant Sun, while the Sun hurls him into the whirlwinds of the Ether.
One receives from another, yet all are filled with hatred.
On this path, I too now tread, an exile from the gods and a wanderer,
Submitting to the frenzied Hatred...

We do not know what his sin consisted of; perhaps it was nothing we would deem particularly grievous. For he states:

Woe to me that the relentless day did not claim me sooner
Than I devised with my lips the vile acts of consumption!
To abstain entirely from laurel leaves!
Unfortunate, thrice unfortunate! Do not touch the beans!

Thus, he likely committed nothing worse than munching on laurel leaves or greedily devouring beans. The most famous passage from Plato, in which he compares this world to a cave where we see only the shadows of real objects from the bright world above, was foreshadowed by Empedocles. The origin of this comparison must be sought in the teachings of the Orphics. Only a few—seemingly those who refrain from sin over many reincarnations—ultimately attain eternal bliss in the company of the gods:

And in the end, they become prophets, singers,
Healers,
And leaders among the living men on earth,
From where they ascend to gods, surpassing all honors.
Those dwelling at a single hearth and sharing meals with other immortals,
Free from human sufferings, invulnerable.

In all this, there appears to be little that was not already contained in the teachings of Orphism and Pythagoreanism. The originality of Empedocles, apart from his scientific contributions, lies in his doctrine of the four elements and the application of the principles of Love and Strife to explain change. He rejected monism and regarded the course of events as governed more by chance and necessity than by purpose. In this respect, his philosophy was more scientific than that of Parmenides, Plato, and Aristotle. In other regards, he silently acquiesced to prevailing prejudices; yet even in this, he was no worse than many later representatives of science.





Über den Autor

Dieser Artikel wurde von Sykalo Yevhen zusammengestellt und redigiert — Bildungsplattform-Manager mit über 12 Jahren Erfahrung in der Entwicklung methodischer Online-Projekte im Bereich Philosophie und Geisteswissenschaften.

Quellen und Methodik

Der Inhalt basiert auf akademischen Quellen in mehreren Sprachen — darunter ukrainische, russische und englische Universitätslehrbücher sowie wissenschaftliche Ausgaben zur Geschichte der Philosophie. Die Texte wurden aus den Originalquellen ins Deutsche übertragen und redaktionell bearbeitet. Alle Artikel werden vor der Veröffentlichung inhaltlich und didaktisch geprüft.

Zuletzt geändert: 15/11/2026