Social Philosophy
“Political Society” or the State: Fundamental Approaches
What is the state? The answer to this question unfolds across the history of philosophy.
- The state is the most perfect and highest union of society (Aristotle).
- The state arises from a contract among individuals who were previously in a natural state, characterized as one of “war of all against all” (Thomas Hobbes). The central idea of the social contract is popular sovereignty, where the people are the source and bearers of power within society.
- The state is a mechanism for maintaining the dominance of one class over another (Lenin).
- The state is primarily a plan of action, a program of cooperation, a call from one group of people directed toward another (José Ortega y Gasset).
Cicero wrote that the state exists to safeguard each individual’s property and enhance it.
The republican state represents a common inheritance encompassing societal structures, laws, customs, and traditions. These societal assets attach themselves to the private property of citizens through the enrichment and complexity of life achieved by uniting individuals within the state.
Max Weber provided a functional understanding of the state as the sole institution with the legal right to exercise force within a given territory. The state guarantees the growth of both societal and personal wealth, alongside the preservation of citizens’ rights and freedoms.
Key Characteristics of the State
A significant characteristic of the state is:
- a) Public authority, exercised openly before all and acting on behalf of the public, which stands distinct from the masses and remains instantly recognizable through attire, stature, symbols, and the like;
- b) The territorial division of the population or the organization of subjects by geographic territory;
- c) The maintenance of this public authority through contributions exacted from citizens in the form of taxes.
Thus, through the possession of public authority and the right to levy taxes, officials who initially act as representatives of society eventually elevate themselves above it.
The history of societal development reveals an extraordinary diversity of forms of state power:
- a) Depending on the number of individuals—one, several, or all—endowed with supreme state authority;
- b) According to the manner in which the supreme head governs the populace, regardless of who that head may be.
The first criterion is termed the form of governance, with possible types of power including democratic, aristocratic, oligarchic, monarchic, tyrannical, totalitarian, and so forth.
Democratic power exists when the majority governs the state, enacting laws and appointing officials at discretion. Here, a distinctive equality prevails, leveling citizens regardless of wealth or origin.
Aristocratic governance occurs when power resides neither with the wealthy nor the poor, but with those deemed noble within the state, a status typically determined by lineage.
Oligarchy, or rule by the few, refers to power held by a small, closed, and tightly knit group. This group is characterized by a stringent property qualification where voting rights are restricted to citizens possessing a set minimum of wealth, ensuring the wealthy always remain fewer than the poor.
Monarchy is rule by a single authority, a word derived from the Greek words mono (one) and arch (rule). The term “monarchy” was introduced by Aristotle. Royal power could derive from law or lineage. It came by law in Carthage, where it was sold at auction, or by lineage in Macedonia and Sparta, where kings were chosen from a single family line. If feudalism represents a system of multiple powers—where personal dependencies operate under the rule of “my vassal’s vassal is not my vassal”—then absolute monarchy overcomes those personal dependencies. It curtails individual arbitrariness to establish a unified structure of authority. The monarch is perceived as primus inter pares (first among equals).
Tyranny is the power of a single ruler attained through cunning or force.
Ochocracy represents the rule of the masses, which invariably aligns with tyranny.
Totalitarianism (statism) is the highest form of direct political violence elevated to norm and system, where anonymous masses exert their will on behalf of the state through the means of this anonymous machine. This is a phenomenon of the 20th century.
The ancient Greeks observed that royal power, grounded in the capriciousness of a singular ruler, easily degenerates into tyranny. Meanwhile, the power of the optimates—those considered the best—transforms into the rule of the wealthy and noble. Consequently, unrestrained popular power leads to disastrous outcomes. This results in “the corruption and tyranny of the mob.” Such distorted forms of governance no longer qualify as true states, for in these cases, the very essence of the state—understood as a collective enterprise and inheritance of the people—entirely vanishes.
Thus, depending on the number of individuals endowed with supreme authority, power may rest with one person, several persons, or all.
The form of governance, meaning the manner in which the state exercises its complete power, may be either republican or despotic.
Republicanism is a principle of state authority that entails the separation of legislative power from the government and judiciary. This idea was proposed in the 18th century by Montesquieu.
Despotism, by contrast, is the arbitrary dictation of laws by the state, where public authority is exercised as the private will of the ruler. For the people, the manner of governance matters far more than the formal structure of the state.
Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn points to a phenomenon of Soviet power known as extrajudicial retribution, a grim mandate assumed by the Cheka, the All-Russian Extraordinary Commission for Combating Counter-Revolution and Sabotage. This organization stands as the only punitive body in human history to combine surveillance, arrest, prosecution, trial, and execution into a single apparatus.
Law, Freedom, and the Constitutional State
Karl Jaspers writes that two fundamental claims are inherent to every human being:
- the demand for protection from violence;
- the demand for recognition of the significance of one’s views and will.
The rule of law provides protection, whereas democracy acknowledges the significance of one’s views and will.
Freedom is achieved only when power is subordinated to law, and it continually strives for an authority that serves the law. This aim is realized within a constitutional state. Laws must hold equal weight for all, and any changes to them can be executed solely through legal channels. In a democracy, this legal expression takes the form of the people’s will. It is manifested through their actions or participation, either directly or through representatives who are entrusted with power and periodically chosen in free elections.
Über den Autor
Dieser Artikel wurde von Sykalo Yevhen zusammengestellt und redigiert — Bildungsplattform-Manager mit über 12 Jahren Erfahrung in der Entwicklung methodischer Online-Projekte im Bereich Philosophie und Geisteswissenschaften.
Quellen und Methodik
Der Inhalt basiert auf akademischen Quellen in mehreren Sprachen — darunter ukrainische, russische und englische Universitätslehrbücher sowie wissenschaftliche Ausgaben zur Geschichte der Philosophie. Die Texte wurden aus den Originalquellen ins Deutsche übertragen und redaktionell bearbeitet. Alle Artikel werden vor der Veröffentlichung inhaltlich und didaktisch geprüft.
Zuletzt geändert: 15/11/2026