Social and Ethnic Communities - The Main Spheres of Social Life: The Social Sphere of Society
Social Philosophy - 2024 Inhalt

The Main Spheres of Social Life: The Social Sphere of Society

Social and Ethnic Communities

Social and ethnic communities occupy a distinctive position among human collectives as the most enduring historically formed groupings of people, whose interrelations serve as a fundamental factor in human history.

Such communities are typically classified as ethnos, tribe, nationality, and nation. The term “ethnos” (derived from the Greek meaning “people”) serves as a general designation for social unities such as tribes, nationalities, and nations. Individuals belonging to the same ethnos share a singular self-awareness regarding their ethnic belonging and identity. Yet what defines this unity?

Among the primary conditions that bind individuals into a people as a coherent social community, commentators frequently cite unity of origin, residence, economic life, language, and culture. Historical facts indicate, however, that none of these conditions in isolation is obligatory.

The Role of History and Social Memory in Ethnic Communities

To grasp what binds an ethnic community into a single entity, one must adopt a historical perspective. Any characteristic of an ethnos may change or even vanish during its historical development. Yet it is this very process of historical evolution that guarantees the unity of the ethnos. We may therefore assert that an ethnos is cemented into a whole by its history, which is preserved in social memory. Social memory connects the various historical states of an ethnos and differentiates its forms of existence across time. All transformations in culture, language, modes of livelihood, and territorial settlement appear within this memory as alterations occurring within a single ethnos.

A notable element of social memory is the self-designation of the ethnos, or ethnonym. The presence of an ethnonym is a necessary condition for ethnic self-awareness. Throughout the history of an ethnos, its self-designation functions as the common name for all its members and as a marker distinguishing it from other groups.

The historical approach allows us to identify two distinct meanings that the concept of “ethnos” assumes in different contexts. These are, first, ethnos as an ethnogenetic community, or ethnic community proper, and second, ethnos as an ethnosocial community.

An ethnogenetic community is a social group whose members are united by an awareness of their genetic connection to other representatives of the group, known as ethnic self-awareness. An individual’s ethnic self-awareness rests on their perception of their origins, with ethnic belonging transmitted as a legacy from ancestors to descendants. This establishes a historical continuity that defines the integrity of the ethnos. Genes alone do not generate ethnic self-awareness; rather, it is determined less by biological factors than by social-psychological ones—specifically, what individuals believe about their origin. An ethnic community is thus a biosocial concept, combining biological and social dimensions.

There exists a multitude of diverse types of ethnic communities. They range from small ethnos numbering only a few hundred individuals, such as Aleuts, Koryaks, and Livonians, to massive populations, with the Chinese being the largest. An ethnos may contain sub-ethnos as components, which differ in specific lifestyle, language, and religious characteristics. Conversely, various ethnos bound by a common socio-historical process can create meta-ethnic formations or super-ethnos, such as the Slavic super-ethnos, the Christian world, or the Muslim world.

The historical conditions in which ethnos exist generate a variety of connections among individuals that extend beyond ethnic characteristics to include political, economic, commercial, and religious ties. Ethnosocial communities are consequently constructed atop ethnogenetic collectives, with economics, the state, religion, and language playing leading roles in their formation. An ethnosocial community is therefore an ethnic collective conditioned by the unity of both ethnic and socio-economic characteristics.

An ethnos is a historical phenomenon. Like individuals, ethnic groups are born, live, and die, giving rise to new ethnos in the process. Depending on the content and direction of socio-economic and political processes, they may assume various forms and types during their self-development, in which biological and social factors intertwine in unique ways.

From Tribes and Nationalities to Modern Nations

As noted previously, the historically primary type of ethnosocial community was the tribal commune. With the evolution of production and social relations, however, a process of tribal consolidation gradually takes place. This results in the formation of tribal alliances in which blood ties progressively yield their dominant role to social connections.

The displacement of kinship relations by commodity relations leads to the dissolution of tribes and their consolidation into nationalities. The formation of nationalities follows the disintegration of primitive society, the emergence of the family and private property, and the establishment of various groupings bolstered by economic ties among allied tribes.

Nationalities are formed on a territorial basis, which means that people living in a certain area are connected through specific economic relations. A nationality is a socio-ethnic community of individuals characterized by a shared territory, a common language alongside various tribal dialects, and elements of a shared culture. Each nationality possesses its own way of life, predominant forms of economic activity, specific rituals, traditions, and a name. Nationalities emerge both from the disintegration of primitive structures replaced by slave societies and from the transition from primitive to feudal society in regions where slave systems were not prevalent.

The formation of bourgeois relations in the modern era creates conditions conducive to the emergence and strengthening of a new system of social connections. The process of solidifying economic ties among individual nationalities, the unification of local markets within particular states into a national market, and various other factors lead to the emergence of a more developed socio-ethnic community of people—a nation.

Theoretical Approaches to Defining the Nation

Currently, within the field of social sciences, there exists no unified understanding or interpretation of the concept of “nation.” This signifies the exceptional complexity, contradiction, and uniqueness of this phenomenon, reflected in the diverse theories of nation. These theories can be broadly categorized into several groups: psychological, cultural, ethnological, and historical-economic.

The founders of the psychological theory of the nation are considered to be the French philosopher and historian E. Renan and the Austrian philosopher O. Bauer. Proponents of psychological concepts view the laws of nation formation and development as derivatives of the consciousness and psyche of individual personalities, the “psychology of peoples.” Thus, Renan asserts that “the nation is a soul, a spiritual principle,” formed through “agreement” and “solidarity” created by the sentiments of past and future generations. O. Bauer notes that the nation is a “collection of people bound together by a shared fate into a community of character.” M. Kareyev regards the nation as a group arising from the direct interaction of individuals.

The cultural approach to the theory of the nation is initiated by K. Renner (Springer). He perceives the nation as a classless spiritual community of individuals, as a subjective unity or cultural alliance born from the consciousness of individuals belonging to a specific ethnic community. A nation, Renner posited, is “a union of individuals who speak the same language” or “a cultural union.” The foundation of the cultural theory of the nation rests upon the commonality of national culture, particularly national language.

The ethnological theory of the nation is grounded in a synthesis of elements from both psychological and cultural theories. Its advocates contend that the principal features of a nation include a shared origin, ethnic self-awareness, national sentiments, and a unity of ethno-spiritual values. However, representatives of ethnological concepts of the nation typically underestimate the significance of social aspects in the development of nations.

The “historico-economic” approach in the theory of nationhood is represented by one of the leading theorists of Marxism, K. Kautsky. In his work “Signs of Nationality,” Kautsky associates the defining characteristics of a nation with a common territory and language, as well as a shared economic life and traditions. He prioritizes the commonality of territory and language, asserting that even in the absence or loss of one or several characteristics, the nation, in his view, continues to exist.

During the Soviet era, the prevailing definition of a nation in domestic literature followed Stalin’s interpretation, which continued the line of the “historico-economic” approach: “A nation is a stable community of people that has historically formed, arising on the basis of a commonality of language, territory, economic life, and psychological composition, manifested in a common culture.” However, Stalin canonized and dogmatized these identified traits. This resulted in the absolutization of the class principle, the division of nations into “state” and “non-state” due to the excessive politicization of national life, and an undervaluation of the role of the national factor in nationhood, among other issues. Notably, Stalin’s definition of a nation remains present in many textbooks even today.

In contemporary scholarly literature, particularly in the West, various definitions of a nation are employed depending on which attributes are emphasized. For instance, the International Edition of the American Encyclopedia describes a nation as “a large number of people who consider themselves a community. They often share one or more of the following attributes: language, culture, religion, political and other institutions, history, and a belief in a common fate. They typically inhabit adjacent territory.” The Dictionary of American Heritage defines a nation as “the population of a certain territory, possessing shared customs, origin, history, and often language.” Webster’s International Dictionary considers a nation to be “a community of people composed of one or more nationalities, having a more or less defined territory and government.”

In the reference book Interethnic Relations: Terms and Definitions, the category nation is defined as an ethnosocial community with a stable self-awareness of its identity. This community is characterized by a shared historical destiny, psychology and character, attachment to national material and spiritual values, national symbolism, and national-ecological sentiments. It is also characterized by territorial-linguistic and economic unity, which is primarily present during the formation stage. Under the influence of integration and migration processes, this unity may manifest ambiguously and often lose its decisive significance, though it does not disappear.

National Culture, Self-Awareness, and Identity

Nevertheless, regardless of the historical paths leading to the creation of a nation or the factors regarded as dominant in its formation, one essential condition for its existence is the establishment of a national culture. In this context, the nation emerges as its collective bearer. The upbringing and development of an individual within the familial and domestic environment, that is, within a specific national-cultural milieu, is effectively equated with the question of their ethnonational origin. The foundation of this national-cultural environment is created by language. Thus, the most significant marker of national affiliation becomes the native language. Modern nations are predominantly linguistic nations, comprised of individuals who speak a common language. Language opens the gateway to national culture: alongside the linguistic shell, the meaningful filling is also comprehended—cultural traditions, value orientations, ideals, norms of thought and behavior, and so forth. Therefore, an individual’s national belonging is their affiliation with national culture.

However, the mere presence of a national-cultural factor does not guarantee the automatic creation of a nation. A community becomes a nation only when and to the extent that its members recognize their unity as a national identity. This relates to national self-awareness as a necessary condition for the existence of a nation. National self-awareness, like other collective representations, is a real social fact and an element of social reality. It influences behavior and interactions among people, with the consequences of this being concrete circumstances in their lives.

National self-awareness arises from comparing one’s own people with others. For each nation, there exists a reference group that embodies relatively stable national traits. This group effectively personifies the generalized image of the nation, which representatives of other nations consult when defining the distinctions of their own characteristics.

To denote an individual’s ethnic origin within a specific nation, the term nationality is often employed. However, this term is frequently regarded as synonymous with nation. In Soviet countries, the concept of a nation coincided with passport nationality. In the West, the terms nation and nationality generally refer to the population of a country, meaning all its citizens regardless of ethnic origin. Thus, for example, in America, descendants of immigrants refer to themselves as Americans according to their citizenship, while emphasizing their ethnic background, such as an American of French, Ukrainian, or Chinese descent. In England, there is but one nationality—Britons.

At a mundane level, the image of a nation is typically associated with an ethnocultural stereotype. An ethnocultural stereotype is a generalized notion of the typical traits characterizing a particular people. There are auto-stereotypes, which are views of one’s own people, and hetero-stereotypes concerning other peoples. Both types of stereotypes are formed and solidified within society as widely accepted traditional views. Moreover, stereotypes often acquire emotional overtones, resulting in the same phenomenon receiving different evaluations, whether positive or negative.

National Character and Ethnocultural Stereotypes

The aggregate of stable traits characteristic of representatives of a given people, which manifests in their activities and interactions, is defined as national character. The essence of this phenomenon can be interpreted from two aspects:

  1. in a personal-psychological sense, where national character is understood as a specific set of personal psychological and moral qualities that distinguish a member of that nation. This character comprises the collection of typical psychological and moral attributes of the people;
  2. in a cultural-normative aspect, whereby national character embodies not the personal traits of all or most individual members of the people, but rather the socio-cultural activities of the nation. This represents the collective spiritual disposition that conditions such activity and manifests within it. To denote the totality of deep-seated orientations of collective consciousness, terms such as mentality and mentalité are employed. National character serves as a form of expression for the mentality of a people. It creates the spiritual atmosphere that exists in society and is manifested in culturally prescribed patterns of thought and behavior, norms, value orientations, and cultural developmental products.

All this indicates that a nation is an extraordinarily complex and dynamic organism, constantly undergoing change and development. Various characteristics of a nation may gain priority at different stages of its development. Thus, during the formative stage of a nation, territorial-linguistic and economic unity play particularly significant roles. In the process of further development, especially in light of migration processes, a nation may branch into a diaspora, where territorial-linguistic and economic unity no longer assume the crucial role they held during its formation. In this period, national self-awareness becomes paramount.

The development of national-ethnic communities reveals two interconnected tendencies: 1) ethnic differentiation—the process of distinguishing and separating a particular social-ethnic community, reflecting its level of political maturity and the subsequent aspiration for national independence and sovereignty; 2) integration, which entails the dismantling of national "barriers," the development and expansion of connections between various nations, social-ethnic communities, and the deepening of economic and cultural relations among them.





Über den Autor

Dieser Artikel wurde von Sykalo Yevhen zusammengestellt und redigiert — Bildungsplattform-Manager mit über 12 Jahren Erfahrung in der Entwicklung methodischer Online-Projekte im Bereich Philosophie und Geisteswissenschaften.

Quellen und Methodik

Der Inhalt basiert auf akademischen Quellen in mehreren Sprachen — darunter ukrainische, russische und englische Universitätslehrbücher sowie wissenschaftliche Ausgaben zur Geschichte der Philosophie. Die Texte wurden aus den Originalquellen ins Deutsche übertragen und redaktionell bearbeitet. Alle Artikel werden vor der Veröffentlichung inhaltlich und didaktisch geprüft.

Zuletzt geändert: 15/11/2026