The Human Being in The System of Social Relations
Freedom of Personality and Responsibility
Freedom is a fundamental philosophical category characterizing the essence of humanity and its existence. It encapsulates the individual’s capacity to think and act according to personal beliefs and desires rather than through internal or external coercion. Throughout the history of philosophical thought, this concept has evolved from a ‘negative’ interpretation—freedom from—to a ‘positive’ one—freedom for. Philosophers such as Kant, Hegel, Schopenhauer, Nietzsche, Sartre, Jaspers, Berdyaev, and Solovyov have all contemplated the nature of human freedom. It has been examined in relation to necessity, caprice, anarchy, equality, and justice.
The range of interpretations for this concept is remarkably broad. It spans from the total denial of the possibility of free choice, as seen in behaviorist theories, to the justification of the ‘flight from freedom’ described by E. Fromm in the context of contemporary civilization. The notion of freedom is often correlated with the concept of will, and the two are frequently regarded as identical (Vladik Nersesyants). Free will is the potential for an individual’s inner self-determination in pursuing various goals. In the annals of philosophical and theological thought, the idea of free will has been linked to human reason, personal responsibility for one’s actions, the fulfillment of duty, and the awareness of purpose. Differing responses to the possibility of free will are determined by one’s choice of a particular worldview. Will represents a conscious and voluntary striving toward a goal that holds specific value for the individual. The act of will manifests as a spiritual phenomenon originating within the structure of a person’s personality. It stands in opposition to impulsive urges and desires, and in some cases, to vital needs, such as in instances of suicide. Typically, the concept of will is attributed to a mature personality that fully controls its actions and behaviors.
Historically, will has been interpreted in two primary ways. It is seen as a result of natural or supernatural determinism, such as the will of God or the Absolute. Alternatively, it is viewed as a self-affirming force that dictates the entire life process of the individual, as argued by Schopenhauer and Nietzsche. The volitional qualities of a person are determined partly by genetics and partly by the surrounding environment, integrating into the structure of the personality’s character.
To comprehend the essence of personal freedom, one must grapple with the contradictions between voluntarism and fatalism and delineate the boundaries of necessity. Voluntarism acknowledges the supremacy of will—subjective or objective—over other manifestations of human spiritual life, including thought. The roots of voluntarism can be traced back to Christian dogma and the teachings of Kant, Fichte, Schopenhauer, Hartmann, and Nietzsche. In this view, will is perceived as a blind, irrational principle that imposes its laws upon humanity. As an extreme manifestation of ethical relativism, voluntarism finds its expression predominantly in social-political practice, where attempts are made to resolve societal issues without regard to objective laws.
Fatalism, in contrast, defines the entire course of a person’s life and actions as being absolutely dependent on fate, the will of God, or the determinism of a closed system where each event is rigidly tied to previous ones, as seen in the systems of Hobbes, Spinoza, and Laplace. In such frameworks, there is virtually no room for free choice, as alternatives do not exist. The strict necessity and predictability of the primary stages of human life are characteristic of astrology and other occult doctrines, as well as various social utopias and dystopias.
At the same time, it is evident that a disregard for necessity—whether natural or historical—is intolerable. This leads to caprice and permissiveness, anarchy and chaos, all of which exclude freedom. Thus, one may conclude that freedom is something greater than the mere acknowledgment of objective necessity and the removal of external constraints. Far more significant is inner freedom, the ‘freedom for,’ which is the pursuit of truth, goodness, and beauty.
The most essential characteristic of freedom is its internal determination, which is imbued with specific content within the framework of the individual-society system. Several models of the relationship between the individual and society concerning freedom can be distinguished.
First, there is the relationship of struggle, where the individual enters into open conflict with society to realize personal goals. Second, there is the escape from the world, a form of escapism in which an individual, recognizing the impossibility of being free within the existing social environment, retreats into a monastery or into their own inner world to fulfill their desire for freedom. Third, an individual may adapt to society, sacrificing the aspiration for freedom and voluntarily submitting to social conditions to achieve a modified form of liberty.
The interests of the individual and society in attaining freedom converge in the process of democratic development. This convergence has necessitated a reevaluation of freedom in the context of the interaction between society and the individual. Whereas freedom was once perceived primarily as the absence of state coercion, by the mid-20th century it became evident that the concept must be supplemented by the regulation of human activity. However, the state should not resort to methods of violence and coercion. Instead, it should employ economic mechanisms while strictly adhering to human rights.
In 1789, the National Assembly of France adopted the Declaration of the Rights of Man and Citizen. It proclaimed that “the aim of any political association is the preservation of the natural and inalienable rights of man. These rights are: freedom, property, security, and resistance to oppression.” Human rights are not granted by external authorities. They are inherent to the individual from birth.
The state is obligated to protect human rights, founded on the principle that the value of the human personality transcends that of any nation, class, or collective. This principle serves as a safeguard against the totalitarian suppression of the individual. Neglecting or subordinating individual rights to the interests of the social collective inevitably leads to the degradation of both the individual and society. Conversely, one must acknowledge that a purely individualistic model of the relationship between individual-society also harbors significant drawbacks. Within such a framework, self-serving motives, egoism, and various forms of social injustice can be legitimized. A ‘golden mean’ is required—one that fosters the vitality of both society and the individual, as well as the development of humanity within humanity. As Hegel noted, for one who is not free, others cannot be free either.
This reveals the organic connection between freedom and law. The fundamental significance of freedom for human existence concurrently expresses the role of law in the social life of individuals. The historical process of liberating individuals from various forms of personal dependence, oppression, and subjugation is simultaneously a legal advancement—an evolution in the formal expression, existence, and protection of freedom. In this sense, history represents a progressive movement toward greater freedom for an increasing number of people. From a legal perspective, this process signifies that a growing number of individuals are recognized as formally equal subjects of the law.
Freedom is the most complex and deeply contradictory phenomenon of human life, possessing immense allure while simultaneously functioning as a heavy burden. The resolution of the tension surrounding freedom depends on the prevailing system of cultural norms and values. When discussing human values, we refer to the universality of the concept, which cannot be reduced to the mere ‘utility’ of an individual to society. The value of the human personality is, in a certain sense, greater than the sum of a person’s actions or words. It cannot be reduced to labor, creativity, or social recognition. Objective criteria and subjective evaluations by contemporaries are often characterized by their one-sidedness.
History repeatedly demonstrates that the true scale and direction of an individual’s thoughts and actions become evident only after many years, or even centuries. Thus, the worth of a person cannot be measured solely by the fruits of their labor. In leaving behind objects, children, and ideas, an individual cannot be reduced to the sum of this legacy.
A significant phenomenon of cultural measure lies in the artifacts created by humanity throughout its historical journey. The world of objects encompasses everything from ancient pyramids to cutting-edge computers, spacecraft, and synthetic materials. This is the domain of material culture, fashioned by humans to satisfy their needs, constituting the ‘inorganic body’ of humanity—a construct that amplifies strength and objectifies human abilities and talents. This domain has become humanity’s ‘second nature,’ and it is no coincidence that one’s valuation of it serves as a precise criterion for an individual’s character. The relationship between human worth, life, health, and property has always been central to any worldview.
Christianity regards those who drown in material possessions and sensual pleasures as ‘carnal,’ incapable of true soulfulness and spirituality. Sharing one’s possessions with the poor stands as one of the guiding principles of Islam, an indispensable rule of conduct for a Muslim. Buddhists assert that the renunciation of accumulation is among the first steps on the path to enlightenment.
The essence of the problem of value and the evaluation of the material world lies in discerning the boundaries of this world and its influence on the development of human personality. It is evident that people cannot subsist on a minimal set of objects, yet the ideals of asceticism have never enjoyed widespread acceptance. Likewise, there is no upper limit to the saturation of this world, and the quantity of objects continues to rise.
Furthermore, one of the reasons for the acute ecological crisis is the accumulation of industrial detritus that cannot be repurposed. The conversion of the planet’s resources into objects occurs at an accelerated pace, provoking serious concern among scholars and politicians. This trend simultaneously fuels mass movements that advocate for the renunciation of unchecked consumption and voluntary self-restraint, such as Gandhism. Given the rapid growth of the Earth’s population and its finite resources, it becomes clear that without self-restraint, we cannot prevail. Yet this requires the development of an appropriate value system within each individual.
Objects, in themselves, hold a neutral value. Valuation arises only within a specific social context, implying an inherent property of society to continuously assess various phenomena, ‘inscribing’ or correlating them with traditional value systems. This pertains fully to the system of spiritual values and their role in shaping the individual.
Spiritual values represent a unique capital of humanity, accumulated over millennia, which typically appreciates rather than depreciates. Axiology is the theory of values, studies the nature of these values and elucidates their relationship to the reality of human life. This field primarily concerns moral and aesthetic values, which are deemed superior because they largely determine human behavior within other value systems. In the context of moral values, the central questions involve the relationship between good and evil, the nature of happiness and justice, the conflict between love and hatred, and the meaning of life. Throughout history, various attitudes have emerged and succeeded one another, reflecting diverse value systems and shaping distinct types of personality.
Hedonism is one of the oldest such attitudes, asserting that pleasure is the highest good in life and the primary criterion for human conduct. The author of Ecclesiastes articulated this notion: “There is nothing better for a man under the sun than to eat, drink, and be merry.” Such views were echoed by Socrates’ disciple, Aristippus, who taught that “the best fate lies not in abstaining from pleasures, but in mastering them without being subjugated.” Later adherents of this position included Epicurus, Hobbes, Locke, Gassendi, Helvétius, and Holbach.
The ethics of asceticism proclaim that the ideal life involves the voluntary renunciation of pleasures and desires, a cult of suffering and loss, and the rejection of worldly comforts and privileges. This concept reached its zenith in Christianity, particularly within monasticism, and in the philosophical schools of the Cynics—exemplified by Diogenes and his motto, “to be naked and alone”—as well as in various egalitarian doctrines.
The utilitarian framework considers utility to be the highest value and the foundation of morality. According to Jeremy Bentham, the essence of ethical norms and principles is to promote the greatest happiness for the greatest number of people. From the perspective of utilitarian advocate John Stuart Mill, “pleasure is the only good.” Immanuel Kant, on the other hand, posits that the highest value lies in treating each individual solely as an end in themselves, never merely as a means.
Tumultuous social upheavals, the emergence of humanity’s potential for self-destruction, the intensification of global issues, and the computer revolution have sharply highlighted traditional problems within spiritual value systems. Universal human concerns, centered on recognizing the absolute value of human life and the preservation of the natural conditions for its existence, are now taking precedence. It is no coincidence that concepts such as “reverence for life” (Albert Schweitzer), “earning the love of one’s neighbor” (Hans Selye), “goals for humanity” (Aurelio Peccei), “the path of nonviolence” (Mahatma Gandhi), and the “noosphere” (Vladimir Vernadsky) have emerged, reflecting the contemporary stage of development of universal ideals.
The same can be said of aesthetic values. Fyodor Dostoevsky’s famous assertion that “beauty will save the world” should not be understood in isolation, but rather within the broader context of the evolution of human ideals. Despite certain deviations, humanity as a whole is moving towards the humanization of relationships, affirming a universal system of values and recognizing the leading role of the individual in progress. Thus, the concepts of personality, freedom, and values enrich our understanding of humanity’s past, present, and future. These dimensions of humanity allow for a proper understanding of society as a phenomenon born from human activity.
Über den Autor
Dieser Artikel wurde von Sykalo Yevhen zusammengestellt und redigiert — Bildungsplattform-Manager mit über 12 Jahren Erfahrung in der Entwicklung methodischer Online-Projekte im Bereich Philosophie und Geisteswissenschaften.
Quellen und Methodik
Der Inhalt basiert auf akademischen Quellen in mehreren Sprachen — darunter ukrainische, russische und englische Universitätslehrbücher sowie wissenschaftliche Ausgaben zur Geschichte der Philosophie. Die Texte wurden aus den Originalquellen ins Deutsche übertragen und redaktionell bearbeitet. Alle Artikel werden vor der Veröffentlichung inhaltlich und didaktisch geprüft.
Zuletzt geändert: 15/11/2026