The Human Being in The System of Social Relations
The Problem of Life and Death in Human Spiritual Experience
Life and death are eternal themes in human culture. They have been pondered by prophets and religious founders, philosophers and moralists, artists and writers, educators and healers. Few people have never contemplated the meaning of their existence, the prospect of death, or the possibility of immortality. These questions are addressed and resolved in various ways across nearly all philosophical systems.
In essence, we are faced with a triad: life, death, and immortality. All human spiritual systems emerge from the idea of the contradictory unity of these phenomena. The greatest emphasis is placed on death and the attainment of immortality, while human life is often viewed as a fleeting moment granted to individuals for the purpose of preparing for what follows.
Throughout history and across cultures, reflections on the nature of life have, with few exceptions, been remarkably bleak. Consider the following characterizations: life is suffering (Buddha, Schopenhauer); life is a dream (Vedas, Plato, La Bruyère, Pascal); life is an abyss of evil (the ancient Egyptian text “The Dialogue of a Man with His Spirit”); life is vanity and spiritual ennui (Ecclesiastes). Marcus Aurelius noted that “Life is a struggle and a journey in foreign lands,” while Diderot observed that “All life is but the price of deceptive hopes.” Kierkegaard lamented, “My life is eternal night,… what is life but madness?” and Nietzsche insisted that “All human life is deeply immersed in untruth.” This pessimism resonates through the proverbs and folk wisdom of many civilizations. Ortega y Gasset defined humanity not as a mere union of body and spirit, but as a specifically human drama.
In this sense, the life of each individual is both dramatic and tragic: no matter how successful or long a life may be, the end is inevitable. The author of Ecclesiastes remarked, “While one is among the living, there is hope; for a living dog is better than a dead lion.” Epicurus attempted to resolve this anxiety by asserting: “Accustom yourself to the thought that death has no relation to us. When we exist, death is not present, and when death is present, we do not exist.”
Death and the potential for immortality are the primary drivers of philosophical inquiry, as all our earthly endeavors must be measured against the eternal. Humanity is condemned to reflect on death, a trait that distinguishes us from animals, which are mortal but do not contemplate their fate. An animal may sense the approach of death, yet its behavior often resembles a painful search for solitude. From a biological perspective, death can be seen as the price paid for the complexity of biological systems. Every living organism possesses a mechanism of self-destruction, tied to its genome, which is activated at a specific stage of development. At the same time, there is a persistent striving to simplify this thesis, to prove, and eventually to embody the notion of actual immortality—a state where the organism remains in a constant condition of flourishing. This engenders varied attitudes toward both death and life, though the hallmark of human wisdom is typically a tranquil attitude toward both. As Mahatma Gandhi observed: “We do not know what is better—living or dying. Therefore, we should neither become overly attached to life nor tremble at the thought of death. We must regard both equally. This is the ideal.”
Dimensions of Life and Death
The problem of life, death, and immortality has several dimensions, each highlighting different aspects of a singular phenomenon.
The first dimension is biological, rooted in the constant presence of life and death in the universe and their continual reproduction, a concept aptly reflected in the hypothesis of panspermia. The cosmic aspects of life are emphasized by Friedrich Engels’ well-known definition: “Life is a mode of existence of protein bodies, and this mode of existence consists essentially in the constant self-renewal of the chemical components of these bodies.” Stars, nebulae, and comets are born, live, and die; in this sense, nothing truly disappears. This aspect has been most elaborately developed in Eastern philosophy and mystical teachings, which posit the fundamental impossibility of comprehending the cosmic cycle through reason alone. Materialistic concepts are instead constructed upon the phenomena of self-generation and self-causality.
The awareness that human life is inextricably linked to the biosphere and potential forms of life in the universe bears immense significance. The idea of the sanctity of life—the right to existence for any living being by virtue of its birth—belongs to the eternal ideals of humanity. In this view, the universe and the Earth are seen as living entities, and interference in their natural laws can lead to ecological crises. Humanity emerges as a small part of this living universe, a microcosm that has absorbed the richness of the macrocosm.
The second dimension of the problem pertains to the specificity of human life and its distinction from the life of other beings. What constitutes this specificity? It is often believed to be the awareness of impending death: we know of it and seek a path to immortality. Other living beings quietly complete their course after reproducing. Humans, however, are condemned to perpetual, painful reflections on the meaning of life. To some extent, this is true, but how does one reconcile this with the death of a newborn child, who has not yet had the opportunity to understand anything, or that of an individual with an impaired psyche? Should we consider the beginning of human life to be the moment of conception or the moment of birth?
The specificity of human life, death, and immortality is clearly not tethered to reason or its manifestations, nor to an individual’s worldly successes or the judgments of posterity. While the premature death of a genius is undeniably tragic, there is no basis for asserting that a longer life would have yielded greater contributions. In this sense, life and the death elude the categories of rational cognition, refusing to conform to a rigidly deterministic model of the world. One can contemplate these concepts rationally only up to a limit dictated by personal interest and each individual’s capacity for an intuitive grasp of the boundaries of existence. The uniqueness and irreplaceability of the human condition find their highest expression here, fostering a diversity of meaning when we reflect upon our mortality.
Five Forms of Immortality
The third dimension of this problem concerns the concept of immortality, which may be categorized into several distinct types.
The first type of immortality exists in the genes of one’s descendants, a notion prevalent among the vast majority of people. A powerful human drive is the desire to see one’s own traits reflected in children, grandchildren, and great-grandchildren. This encompasses not only the inheritance of physical features but also the transmission of moral qualities and specific aptitudes.
The second type of immortality pertains to the mummification of the body to ensure its eternal preservation. The historical experience of Egyptian pharaohs and the practices of modern embalming demonstrate that this desire is accepted in certain civilizations. Late 20th-century technological advances have even made the cryopreservation of the deceased possible, fueled by the hope that future medical science might revive them and cure currently untreatable diseases. Such fixation on the physical body is typically characteristic of totalitarian societies, where gerontocracy becomes the foundation of a stable state.
The third type of immortality involves the dissolution of the deceased’s body and spirit into the universe, effectively incorporating them into the cosmic body and the eternal cycle of matter. This perspective is characteristic of certain Eastern civilizations, particularly in Japan. It aligns with the Islamic view of life and death, as well as with various naturalistic concepts. This approach implies the loss of individual personality, as remnants of the former body integrate into other living organisms.
The fourth type of immortality is tied to the fruits of human creative life. Scientific discoveries, the creation of a seminal literary or artistic work, the exercise of statesmanship, or a significant military victory—all serve to etch an individual’s name into the memory of descendants. Yet, human memory preserves the names of heroes, creators, and prophets alongside those of the most brutal tyrants and notorious criminals. This raises difficult questions regarding how we evaluate the true magnitude of a personality.
The fifth type of immortality is achieved through altered states of consciousness. Often, these are the products of meditative practices prevalent in Eastern religions and civilizations. Through these methods, individuals seek breakthroughs into new dimensions of space and time, journeys into the past and future, and states of ecstasy and enlightenment that provide a mystical sense of connection to Eternity. ⟦n⟧
Religious Perspectives on Mortality
The meaning of death and immortality, and the paths to achieving them, represent the reverse side of the problem of the meaning of life. These questions are addressed differently depending on prevailing cultural and worldview orientations, with national traditions, religious beliefs, and civilizational characteristics playing significant roles. Of particular interest is the impact of major religious movements—Christianity, Islam, and Buddhism—on how these cultures navigate the concepts of life, death, and immortality. ⟦n⟧
Christianity’s understanding of this problem is grounded in the Old Testament assertion that “the day of death is better than the day of birth” and in Christ’s command from the New Testament: “…I hold the keys of hell and death.” The divine-human essence of this faith manifests in the belief that the immortality of the individual as a whole being is attainable only through resurrection. The path to this is opened by Christ’s redemptive sacrifice on the cross. This is a domain of mystery and miracle; humanity is drawn out of the sphere of natural-cosmic forces and brought, as a person, face to face with God, who is also a person. ⟦n⟧
Thus, the goal of human life is theosis, a path toward eternal life. Without this realization, earthly existence transforms into a dream. It serves essentially as preparation for the eternal life that awaits everyone. This is not a tragedy, but rather a transition to another world where countless souls reside and where each individual enters for joy or suffering. Death, therefore, does not destroy the person but rather their perishability; it is not an end, but the beginning of eternal life. ⟦n⟧
Christianity connects its understanding of immortality with the figure of Ahasuerus, the ‘Eternal Jew.’ As Jesus, bearing the cross, journeyed to Golgotha and wished to rest, Ahasuerus stood among the crowd and urged him, “Go on, go on.” For this, he was punished and denied the rest of the grave. He was doomed to wander the world until the second coming of Christ, who alone can free Ahasuerus from his forced and loathsome immortality. ⟦n⟧
Christianity categorically condemns suicide, as the individual does not belong to themselves; their life and death are held within the will of God.
Islam, by contrast, posits that human life begins through the will of the Almighty Allah, a deity defined primarily by mercy. Unlike in Christianity, earthly existence is highly valued in the Islamic tradition. Yet, this life is finite; on the Day of Judgment, the world will be destroyed, and the dead will rise to face their final reckoning before Allah. Belief in the afterlife is foundational, as it compels individuals to evaluate their actions not by the yardstick of personal interest, but by the weight of eternal consequence. ⟦n⟧
The destruction of the universe on the Day of Judgment anticipates the creation of a new, perfect world. Each person will be presented with a record of their deeds and thoughts, leading to an appropriate verdict. In this framework, moral and rational laws hold supremacy over physical ones. A morally pure individual cannot remain in a state of humiliation, as so often happens in temporal life. Islam also categorically prohibits suicide; one must not presume to ask Allah for the time of death, for that knowledge belongs to Him alone. ⟦n⟧
In Buddhism, the perspective on death and immortality differs markedly from the Abrahamic traditions. The Buddha himself refrained from declaring whether one who has realized the truth is mortal or immortal. Can someone who has grasped the truth be both simultaneously? Essentially, only one form of “strange immortality” is acknowledged: nirvana, the embodiment of a transcendent, attribute-less Absolute Being. The individual is viewed as a sum of moments, flowing perpetually through cycles of reincarnation, which renders the chain of natural births absurd. As the “Dhammapada” asserts, rebirth is painful, and thus life is suffering. Escape lies in the path to nirvana by breaking free from the chain of endless rebirths to achieve enlightenment, that blessed “island” within the depths of the human heart. The symbol of nirvana—the extinguishing of the fire of life that eternally devours—expresses the essence of the Buddhist understanding of death and immortality. As the Buddha remarked, “One day of life for a person who has seen the immortal path is better than a century of existence for one who has not glimpsed the higher life.” ⟦n⟧
A similar composure regarding life, death, and immortality, coupled with the pursuit of enlightenment and liberation from evil, characterizes other Eastern religions and sects. In this context, the attitude toward suicide shifts. It is viewed not as a sin, but as a senseless act, for it does not liberate a person from the cycle of births and deaths (samsara), but merely leads to rebirth in a lower state. One must overcome attachment to individuality. As the Buddha said, “the nature of personality is perpetual death.” Liberation in life from the causes of suffering and the dominion of the “self” is the superior path to achieving immortality. ⟦n⟧
Atheistic and Non-Religious Approaches
The history of human spiritual life encompasses various non-religious and atheistic approaches to the problems of life, death, and immortality. Several alternative paths for resolving these questions can be distinguished. ⟦n⟧
The first path accepts the scientifically and rationally substantiated principle that the complete annihilation of even an elementary particle is impossible, and that the universe is governed by laws of conservation. Substance, energy, information, and the organization of complex systems are all preserved. Thus, parts of our “self” enter the eternal cycle of being after death and, in this sense, become immortal. They do not, however, possess the consciousness or soul tied to our individual identity. Furthermore, this form of immortality is attained throughout one’s life, leading to the paradoxical realization that we live only because we die every second. Red blood cells perish daily, epithelial cells slough off our mucous membranes, hair is shed, and so on. It is therefore fundamentally impossible to frame life and death as absolute opposites; they are two sides of a singular process. ⟦n⟧
Before death, all are equal; it dissolves the inequalities upon which earthly life is built. A tranquil acceptance of the absence of eternal life for the individual “self,” combined with the understanding that one must inevitably merge with an “indifferent” nature, represents one avenue of a non-religious approach to the problem. This, however, raises the question of the Absolute as a criterion for one’s moral decisions. ⟦n⟧
The second path seeks immortality through human endeavors, manifested in the fruits of material and spiritual production. The rational basis for this path lies in the notion of the immortality of humanity and its cosmic purpose. If we acknowledge that self-destruction via thermonuclear or ecological catastrophe, or demise through cosmic cataclysms, remains a real possibility, the question of humanity’s future stays open. Among the ideals driving this form of immortality are the struggles for liberation from social oppression, national independence, and statehood. These pursuits provide humanity with a higher meaning of life, one closely intertwined with the idea of immortality. ⟦n⟧
The third path leads to immortality through immersion in the flow of everyday life, and in the daily tasks and concerns that shape our existence. ⟦n⟧
Other concepts of immortality seek to alter the laws of nature, such as the notion of a ‘common cause’ proposed by M. Fedorov or the pantheism inspired by thinkers including A. Einstein. These range from the pursuit of ‘life after death’ as discussed by R. Moody and A. Ford, to various mystical currents that acknowledge the reality of an afterlife and the possibility of communicating with the departed. Some suggest that each individual possesses a unique energetic phantom that detaches shortly before physical death to continue existing in other dimensions. This notion fosters a new understanding of immortality, one linked to the necessity of self-definition within an eternal domain of informational and energetic entities.
Thanatology, Bioethics, and Euthanasia
Thanatology is the scientific and humanitarian study of death. Interest in this field stems from several factors, most notably the current global civilizational crisis, which threatens humanity with potential self-destruction while simultaneously shifting value systems regarding life and death. The new dilemmas arising from scientific and medical advancements—such as organ transplantation, genetic engineering, and in vitro fertilization—have spurred the formation of bioethics, a comprehensive discipline straddling philosophy, ethics, biology, and medicine. This development coincides with a heightened focus on human rights, particularly concerning one’s own corporeal and spiritual existence and society’s response to threats against life on Earth. Today, bioethics encompasses complex issues including euthanasia, decortication, abortion, suicide, organ transplantation, reproductive technologies like surrogacy, genetic engineering, sexual identity, and attitudes toward mental health. These issues are addressed through the lens of existing normative and ethical frameworks within global and national traditions and legal systems.
Particular attention is paid to euthanasia, literally a ‘happy death,’ as a modern social phenomenon requiring serious philosophical reflection. The term emerged in the modern era and is associated with F. Bacon, who used it to denote a painless death intended to alleviate the suffering caused by incurable illness. This phenomenon is rooted in the concept of a person’s right not only to life but also to death, a position that intersects with the question of suicide. Several types of euthanasia are distinguished: active voluntary, active involuntary, passive voluntary, and passive involuntary.
In addressing the legality and moral justification of euthanasia, physicians face a dilemma known since the time of Hippocrates. A physician must not be a murderer, even at a patient’s request, yet they are also bound by the duty to alleviate the suffering of the ill.
The Search for the Meaning of Life
Within the context of the relationship between life, death, and immortality, the problem of the meaning of life gains particular significance. For those with a religious or idealistic worldview, the purpose of humanity is placed beyond the individual, serving as a means to achieve an afterlife. In contrast, from a materialistic perspective, human life lacks any externally granted purpose. Because the meaning of life does not exist as an objective reality outside of an individual’s consciousness, each of us must construct our own meaning; no one can undertake this task for us. As V. Frankl noted, meaning cannot be given; it must be found. This leads to several properties of the meaning of life:
- The meaning of life is individual: it exists for the subject, and each person possesses their own unique sense of purpose.
- The meaning of life is subjective: it does not exist until the subject acknowledges it.
- The meaning of life does not arise automatically; it is consciously defined by the individual through their will and effort.
When discussing the search for the meaning of life, one must recognize that the issue cannot be resolved in purely biological terms. Instead, it must be considered a social phenomenon—the meaning of human life within society. This implies that individual life gains meaning as a fragment of the collective, shared life of humanity. Life is imbued with meaning when personal happiness becomes the happiness of others. Conversely, a person who lives solely for themselves loses the meaning of life precisely because they sever their individual existence from the broader life of society.
Über den Autor
Dieser Artikel wurde von Sykalo Yevhen zusammengestellt und redigiert — Bildungsplattform-Manager mit über 12 Jahren Erfahrung in der Entwicklung methodischer Online-Projekte im Bereich Philosophie und Geisteswissenschaften.
Quellen und Methodik
Der Inhalt basiert auf akademischen Quellen in mehreren Sprachen — darunter ukrainische, russische und englische Universitätslehrbücher sowie wissenschaftliche Ausgaben zur Geschichte der Philosophie. Die Texte wurden aus den Originalquellen ins Deutsche übertragen und redaktionell bearbeitet. Alle Artikel werden vor der Veröffentlichung inhaltlich und didaktisch geprüft.
Zuletzt geändert: 15/11/2026