The Essence of Social Diagnosis - Social Diagnosis, Forecasting, and Design
Foundations of social philosophy - 2024 Inhalt

Social Diagnosis, Forecasting, and Design

The Essence of Social Diagnosis

Subject activity is an essential condition for realizing the praxeological potential of social and philosophical knowledge, manifesting as a unified mastery of social reality. Social diagnosis, forecasting, and design serve as the primary mechanisms for this mastery. Together, they bridge the gap between theory and practice, linking the individual, the particular, and the general. These processes facilitate the objectification of scientific and philosophical ideas, grounding them in the specific temporal and spatial requirements of the subject’s field of activity. We shall explore these dimensions in the following section.

Investigating the essence of social diagnosis requires several preliminary steps.

  • we must elucidate the etymology of the term.
  • we must clarify the generic characteristics of ‘diagnosis’ alongside specific applications such as political, social, psychodiagnostic, and managerial diagnosis.
  • we must specify the categorical range of social diagnosis and its conceptual equivalents.
  • we must define the semantic content of the metaphors that have shaped the evolution of this field, as these metaphors continue to delineate the methodologies at the frontier of theory and practice.

We hold with L.S. Vygotsky that the terminological problem accounts for a lion’s share of methodological research.

Etymology and Historical Roots of Diagnostic Inquiry

The concepts of ‘diagnosis’ and ‘diagnostics’ originated in Ancient Greece, where they were primarily utilized in medicine to infer an organism’s internal state from its external manifestations. Definitions from the Dictionary of Foreign Words provide a starting point for assessing the semantic load these terms carry today.

Diagnosis [< Greek diagnōsis: recognition, definition] — 1) the determination of a disease and the condition of a patient based on a comprehensive medical examination; 2) in botany and zoology, the scientific description of the primary features characterizing a systematic group, such as a species or genus.

Diagnostics [< Greek diagnōstikos: capable of recognizing] — 1) the branch of medicine that studies the signs of diseases, patient examination methods, and the principles of establishing a diagnosis; 2) the identification and study of signs characterizing the state of technical systems to predict deviations and prevent operational failure; 3) in physics, plasma diagnostics refers to the methods used to measure and study the characteristics and processes within a plasma.

A diagnosis is, on one hand, a determination of an entity’s state when its signs deviate from the norm, and on the other, the identification of the process causing that deviation. This diagnostic procedure is a comprehensive investigation. It serves as the foundation for treatment by encapsulating the essence of the condition under review. In the evolution of the diagnostic approach, the study of pathology and deviation has proven significant. Indeed, the diagnostic process is often reduced solely to the identification of such deviations. Equally vital is the search for axiological and evaluative approaches to diagnostics, which establish its instrumental and measurable significance.

A diagnosis is a collection of an object’s characteristics as reflected by the subject, while diagnostics is the subject’s ability to use specific methods to reflect those characteristics. In this context, diagnosis encompasses several essential aspects of meaning.

  1. The first aspect is the recognition of a problematic situation, such as a disease or a condition whose development threatens destruction. Diagnostics, however, is not confined to the study of pathology; it is also employed to monitor normal states, functional modes, and the execution of ongoing activities. In all instances, the focus remains on objective processes that are vital and possess a problematic character. The ontological aspect of social development manifests here as a necessity for the action and participation of the social subject within social reality.
  2. As a method, diagnostics is characterized by indirect, mediated research based on specific signs. It relies on a model that replaces the system under study—be it an organism, a machine, or a social structure. Diagnostics thus operates as a unity of the ontological and the epistemological, the reflected and the reflecting, the known and the evaluated. The epistemological and axiological unity reflects both the ‘measure of life’ of the society and the subject, as well as the progress of the objective process being analyzed.

Diagnostics often seeks to measure a process or classify an object by assigning it to a known category. This procedure is viable only when the criteria for identification are substantive enough to reflect the objective mechanisms driving the process. Beyond mere classification, diagnostics functions to identify potential states and prevent functional disruptions. This capacity highlights the subject activity involved in controlling life and activity, as well as the subject’s ability to cognize and transform reality within the framework of praxeology.

Diagnostics comprises two essential aspects. First, it functions as a specialized branch of inquiry—analogous to medical diagnostics—concerned with the characteristics of pathological conditions, or significant deviations in system states that may be adaptive or destructive. It encompasses the methods used to investigate signs of these conditions and the study of the fundamental laws that govern a system’s existence and functioning.

Second, diagnostics serves as an epistemological toolkit. It is a system of knowledge that allows the researcher to model an object through its characteristics and signs while mastering the methods required to investigate them. This mastery defines the principles of the subject’s cognition and activity.

When considered as a whole, these methods and tools constitute an epistemological system. This coherence demands that the subject possess not only holistic, systematic thinking but also a refined mastery of diagnostic tools and their application.

The “Great Encyclopedic Dictionary” provides an etymological characterization of diagnosis as both the study of principles for recognizing disease and the process of establishing a diagnosis itself. In this context, a diagnosis is defined as “the determination of the essence and characteristics of diseases based on a comprehensive examination of the patient.” This distinction separates the study of pathology from the practical process of recognition, thereby clarifying the interplay between the epistemology and praxeology of diagnosis.

Conceptualizing Social Diagnosis in Sociology

Social diagnosis is defined by a range of interpretations that reflect its evolving scope. It is understood as “the procedure for determining and recognizing the object of social research,” as “the alignment with social characterization and typology,” or as “a form of human activity… aimed at determining the actual state of a social object for the purposes of further corrective influence on it and altering its condition or mode of operation.”

While these definitions correctly identify that social diagnosis involves subject activity directed toward an object, they remain narrow. By focusing exclusively on the object and its state, they overlook the foundational role of aim-setting. Diagnosis is not merely a reactive classification of social phenomena; it is a goal-oriented process where the intent to transform the object is as essential as the analysis itself.

Yu.P. Surmin and M.V. Tulenko identify states, problems, situations, and processes as the subjects of diagnosis. Diagnosis of states focuses on the stationary characteristics of an object to assess its stability. Evaluation of situations considers an aggregation of events to gauge the danger of a specific context and its potential trajectory.

Examination of problems concentrates on contradictions and their resolution, emphasizing the scale and severity of social issues. Finally, process-oriented diagnosis evaluates the patterns and dynamics of social processes to determine their balance and effectiveness.

The classification proposed by Surmin and Tulenko suffers from a methodological inconsistency: it treats the subject of diagnosis as a collection of singular fragments rather than an integrated whole. Furthermore, by reducing diagnosis to a process of evaluation, this approach frames it as a merely reproductive procedure for classification. This fragmentary view obscures the deeper, transformative potential of diagnostic inquiry.

In reality, these diagnostic fragments are deeply interconnected. A situation—grasped within temporal bounds and characterized by relative stability—is the context in which processes unfold and change. While a situation reflects the objective spatial-temporal characteristics of a ‘node’ of processes, a problem encompasses more. A problem reflects not only the actual state of affairs but also the desired state, as envisioned by the subject in accordance with social norms, values, and requirements.

The Philosophy of Problems and Problematic Situations

In the philosophy of science, scholars distinguish between a problem and a problematic situation. A problem is defined as “a form of theoretical knowledge whose content comprises what remains unknown to humanity, yet needs to be known… a process that encompasses two main moments (stages of cognition)—its formulation and resolution.” In practical terms, this manifests as a problematic situation. Within scientific inquiry, such a situation signals a contradiction where established knowledge fails to account for new findings, necessitating further refinement or total replacement. Because the unknown is envisioned as a desired outcome, a problem represents a problematic situation within the broader development of knowledge in a given field.

Philosophy of science differentiates between two types of problems. Epistemological problems are cognitive in nature, focused on transforming ignorance into knowledge, developing new analytical tools, and expanding the frontiers of understanding. Substantive problems—whether organizational or social—arise from discrepancies between the actual and the desired. These problems highlight the tension between what exists and what ought to be, requiring deliberate societal action to resolve.

In this framework, an epistemological problem constitutes a problematic situation that charts a course for future research. Simultaneously, social diagnosis functions as an inquiry directed toward specific, pressing, and often unique problematic situations.

In philosophy, the category of the ‘problem’ captures several critical dynamics. It tracks the development of contradictions between the demands of an ideal and the conditions available for its realization. It marks the growing inadequacy of existing tools to achieve desired ends. Furthermore, it identifies the escalating risk of systemic disorganization when one relies on outdated methods to manage these tensions. Finally, the problem necessitates the discovery or creation of new methods to resolve these contradictions and unlock new potential.

Sociology has extensively researched the social problem. Its use of this concept involves measuring the gap between the desired and the actual, analyzing the social contradictions that generate problematic situations, and evaluating both the public perception of these issues and society’s capacity to address them. Researchers also use this framework to typify problems and determine appropriate methods for social intervention. Frequently, however, sociology restricts the term ‘problem’ to its narrow epistemological sense, using it merely to denote the focus or direction of a research project.

The problematic situation constitutes the subject of social diagnosis, providing it with its definitional essence. This focus remains consistent throughout every stage of inquiry—from the initial assessment of a state of affairs to the identification of the existing situation. Although sociological and managerial literature may use varying terminology to describe this diagnostic stage, it is universally characterized as a qualitative or quantitative determination of the situation.

Diagnostic Inquiry as a Practical Technology

The role of the problematic situation as the subject of social diagnosis is validated by studies of practically oriented diagnostic inquiry. In sociology, diagnostic procedures are viewed as essential tools for practical activity. When applied to organizations, these procedures function as a technology for generating diagnostic information regarding problematic states.

The distinction between general research and diagnostic approaches lies in their fundamental orientation. General research focuses on uncovering patterns of causality, providing theoretical clarification, and classifying problems. The diagnostic approach, by contrast, targets the ‘specific problems of a particular organization.’ It seeks to translate abstract social phenomena into concrete, actionable problems that can be examined through both theoretical and empirical lenses.

Yu.P. Surmin and M.V. Tulenkov propose a structured approach to social diagnosis: they describe the actual state of the object, determine the desired benchmark state, compare these two conditions, and finally verify whether they correspond. If the states align, practical activity continues in its current mode; if they diverge, the activity must be corrected. This structure creates a cognitive framework for analyzing the problematic situation.

An investigation of the conditions and the actual state of the situation constitutes the first stage. The second stage identifies the requirements necessary to resolve it. A comparison of the gap between existing and desired conditions follows, while the fourth stage involves rigorous measurement and verification. In our view, it is also essential to highlight a final, resultant stage: the actual resolution of the problem, or the consequences of inaction.

V.N. Minin, I.G. Yasavyev, and T.M. Simonova have provided a comprehensive overview of the methodological approaches to social problems. Further investigation into the structure of the subject and the genesis of these methodologies, however, reveals a striking correspondence: the internal structure of social diagnosis mirrors the historical evolution of research into social problems. By examining these methodological approaches through the lens of social diagnosis, we can better articulate the logic behind their development.

Methodological Approaches to Social Problems

The study of social problems rests on several core components: objective conditions of reality, subjective requirements, and the identification of the gap between the two. This ‘gap’—the distance between the actual situation and the necessary requirements (values, norms, and ideals)—forms the basis for task definition. Methodological divergence in this field is largely determined by which of these components a given approach prioritizes.

In the paradigm of social pathology, as well as in Marxist and conflictological traditions, the ‘situation’—the confluence of objective conditions and the assessment of manageable versus unmanageable factors—is central. Social pathology centers on the concept of order, viewing any disruption to the functioning of the ‘social organism’ as pathological. The Marxist tradition, rooted in a materialist conception of history, analyzes problems through the prism of material production and inherent social contradictions. These include the tensions between productive forces and production relations, or between capital and labor. Similarly, the conflictological tradition emphasizes the unequal distribution of resources. It focuses on the resulting struggles over interests, exploitation, and discrimination.

Axiological approaches focus primarily on the ‘gap’ between social requirements and objective conditions, seeking to identify, evaluate, and measure this discrepancy. While these approaches integrate insights from objectivist and functionalist theories, they prioritize the distribution of values and the mechanisms of social integration. In this framework, dysfunction represents subjective activity that fails to meet systemic requirements, thereby weakening institutional ties. The conflict-value school, however, pivots away from purely objective conditions to examine the value-laden world and the mental sphere of social groups.

Recent scholarship has increasingly adopted a subjectivist orientation. Interactionist approaches focus on communication and societal reactions to ‘deviance,’ particularly the process of labeling individuals. Constructivist approaches further abandon the search for objective conditions. They argue instead that a social problem exists only when it is articulated through public demands and sustained by groups seeking to influence social control and administrative resolution.

These methodological shifts have enriched the structure of social diagnosis, grounding it in both practical problem-solving and theoretical reflection. This evolution confirms the integrity of social diagnosis as a rigorous field dedicated to the systematic investigation of social problems and their underlying structures.

Critique of Reproductive Social Cognition

Conversely, a fragmented understanding of social diagnosis risks narrowing its essential characteristics. Yu.P. Surmin and M.V. Tulenkov note that ‘social diagnosis’ is often conflated with general research or simple typification. To distinguish it, they define social diagnosis in a narrow sense as a specific form of reproductive social cognition, characterized by five distinct features. We shall now analyze these fundamental tenets.

  1. “Social diagnostics, by its intended purpose, is not an heuristic, creatively cognitive process, as its tasks do not include the search for and discovery of new laws and trends or the increase of new social knowledge. Its primary purpose is to classify phenomena of social reality under already known categories of events, states, and phenomena of social life… Social diagnostics is the procedure of identifying the state of the object of study with a specific class or type of social phenomena.” This characterization, in our view, severely restricts the essence of the field. To equate social diagnosis solely with the identification of an object within a known taxonomy overlooks the high degree of uncertainty that necessitates expert heuristic methods for modeling a specific problematic situation. Furthermore, social diagnosis often proceeds not from established categories, but from requirements, goals, norms, and ideals applied to atypical states. While classification may rely on a singular criterion, diagnosis often involves a multi-criteria selection that possesses its own procedural specificity. Social diagnosis is not merely a reproductive procedure; it possesses genuine heuristic potential, as new theories frequently emerge from the diagnostic investigation of social situations. While it encompasses classification and typology, it is not reduced to them. Its significance lies in comparing the actual state of an object against social requirements—a process that integrates subjective needs, values, and ideals with the objective constraints of social life. Because not all subjective and objective requirements can be satisfied simultaneously, social diagnosis functions through the interaction of subject activity, reflecting the social measure of life for both the individual and society.
  2. “Social diagnostics includes the typification of signs and phenomena, as well as the identification of empirical models with theoretical ones. After all, social diagnostics is primarily a procedure of successive typifications.” This assertion unjustly narrows the essence of diagnosis to the mere labeling of signs. Such an approach is insufficient, as the diagnostic process is rarely confined to a predetermined theoretical typology. In practice, unexpected developments—hidden interests, emerging goals, or systemic anomalies—frequently arise, fundamentally altering the mechanism of diagnosing a problematic situation. Because deviations in social processes may have a cumulative effect, leading either to collapse or to a qualitative leap in development, reliance on static typification becomes a misguided strategy. Effective diagnosis requires an understanding of both deterministic and stochastic causal relationships to capture the nonlinear, systemic nature of social life. Historical failures illustrate this limitation. For example, the collapse of the Russian state in 1917 was preceded by a systemic crisis involving the exhaustion of the state’s life potential, the delegitimization of the Provisional Government, and the active self-organization of lower social strata. Throughout this period, the state’s diagnostic apparatus continued to produce reports that failed to account for the actual level of social instability, rendering their findings ineffective. A similar failure occurred during the collapse of the USSR. In light of such events, social diagnosis is better understood as an objectively oriented process that reflects the unity of the concrete and the abstract. While it must maintain a practical, concrete orientation, it cannot afford to exclude theoretical and abstract analysis.
  3. “Social diagnostics—assert Yu.P. Surmin and M.V. Tulenkov— as a procedure for reproducing specific social-scientific knowledge often intertwines with scientific inquiry and creativity… in the creation of fundamentally new typologies… with new possibilities for the identification of empirical models with theoretical ones.” This characterization attempts to qualify the reproductive nature of social diagnosis, yet it effectively sidelines the essential stage of theoretical modeling. By omitting this stage, the definition relies solely on empirically oriented models and fails to account for the qualitative modeling of a problematic situation. In contrast, diagnosis as a foundation for forecasting should retain a descriptive, qualitatively defined character capable of capturing both the typical and atypical features of a given situation.
  4. Surmin and Tulenkov further claim that “Social diagnostics… fulfills one of the science’s most crucial functions—the prognostic one. Indeed, without a qualified diagnosis, there can be no qualified prognosis, as the identification of the social state with a specific type of social phenomena (states) implies that this state corresponds to the logic (regularities) of the functioning and development of this type of phenomena, wherein the future of specific, individual phenomena can be traced…” This assertion is reductive. Forecasting cannot rely solely on reproductive comparisons and typologies, as such an approach excludes the possibility of qualitative leaps in societal development and limits all prognosis to mere extrapolation. In truth, social diagnosis functions as an inseparable link between the assessment of a situation and its active transformation. It is a technology for defining a problematic situation, providing the necessary basis for subsequent forecasting, project design, planning, and the continuous organizational management required to realize these goals.
  5. “In determining the social diagnosis, a sufficiently high degree of affinity is observed between social reality and its subjective assessments (ideological or ideational-political).” To mitigate this, the authors suggest either abstaining from assessments entirely or ensuring their objectivity. In practice, however, this supposed objectivity often collapses into a simplistic dichotomy. Under this binary logic, social phenomena, signs, and processes are diagnosed through a process of dismemberment, where every element is forced into one of two polar assessments of its objective social significance.

This characterization is limited because it reduces the ‘proper’ to mere subjective or political evaluation. The requirements inherent in defining a problematic situation are indeed subjective, but they become distorted if they fail to reflect objective social processes, ultimately precluding any effective managerial decision. Therefore, when establishing criteria for addressing a problematic situation, one must avoid the absolutization of the subjective within the dynamics of the subject-subject-object relationship. This remains a critical, albeit singular, aspect of defining the problematic situation in any professional activity.

Social Diagnosis as Management Technology

Social diagnosis functions both as a form of goal-setting for management and as a type of social technology disseminated within the sociocultural space. In the latter capacity, it exhibits the core characteristics of social technology: artificiality, repeatability, replicability, operationality, holistic orientation, logical consistency, and algorithmicity.

V.I. Podshivalina notes, “As for the level of involvement… in management processes, it is prudent to distinguish two types of social technologies. First, we refer to technologies of social diagnosis, wherein the object of algorithmization consists of methods for identifying a social object or its subsystems. Diagnosis itself is, in essence, a technology of change, which is realized through the reflection of representations existing within the organization concerning itself. Furthermore, we may speak of technologies aimed at influencing social processes, where the object of algorithmization pertains to the methods of their implementation.” This perspective demonstrates that the value of social diagnosis lies in its ability to evaluate the fundamental properties of individuals and groups against the general patterns established in sociological knowledge.

V.V. Shcherbina argues that the meaning of “social diagnosis” depends fundamentally on the researcher’s professional vantage point. For the practitioner, diagnosis focuses on information-gathering, aiming to assess an object’s capacity to perform its functions and to determine the necessary corrective interventions. For the developer of diagnostic tools, it is a specialized activity bridging fundamental science and methodology. This subjectivity reveals a complex relationship between the subject and the object. It manifests as a unified process comprising four dimensions:

  • the information-measuring process, which acquires data on the object’s state
  • the objectified-evaluative aspect, which assesses the object’s functional readiness
  • the subject activity aspect, which implements corrective influence
  • the conceptual-modeling process, which develops the diagnostic tools themselves.

Conceptual Frameworks in Sociological Analysis

According to V.I. Podshivalina, sociological science categorizes the analysis of social diagnosis into five distinct conceptual approaches.

The first approach treats social diagnosis as a procedure for detecting an object’s deviations from established norms. A second approach identifies it as a method for pinpointing a problematic situation; unlike the first, this perspective prefers to engage with a healthy social organism rather than one defined by its pathologies. A third approach, the systemic or organic model, views social diagnosis as a means of assessing the integrity of a social system, focusing on its ability to compensate for lost functions. The fourth approach defines social diagnosis as a tool for measuring the correspondence—or lack thereof—between a social object and its ideal state. Finally, the fifth approach interprets social diagnosis as an axiological exercise in determining the significance of a phenomenon, where the relevance of the diagnosis is deeply informed by the trajectory of societal development.

The proposed classification reveals that many of these approaches are variations of a normative framework. While the normative and problem-oriented approaches are often distinguished by the object’s status as “sick” or “healthy,” an illness is essentially a problem that has reached a critical threshold, threatening the system’s existence. Similarly, the system-oriented approach often relies on norms, whether they pertain to stable development or the maintenance of a specific status. The fourth approach, which posits an ideal, clearly establishes a normative standard, as does the fifth, which utilizes axiological procedures to evaluate phenomena against value-based requirements.

Defining the generic traits of social diagnosis helps systematize the relationship between general, particular, and singular phenomena. The problem-oriented approach functions as the general framework, while the particular approaches—such as the situational and normative models—are defined by the dominance of specific structural components. Within the normative category, one can further identify subtypes based on normal, value-based, or ideal evaluative definitions.

Psychodiagnostics and Individual Assessment

Identifying the generic traits of social diagnosis and its associated subject activity is also vital for understanding the related field of psychodiagnosis.

In contemporary international psychology, the term psychodiagnosis refers to the methodologies exemplified by H. Rorschach and other validated tests. It is frequently used as a synonym for psychological testing and encompasses the development and application of diverse measurement tools for assessing individual differences and psychological disturbances.

Internationally, the development of psychodiagnosis has emphasized the measurement of individual differences through projective methods. Advocates of this approach, such as R. Rorschach, M. Mayle, and R. Hayes, have focused on evaluating deviations through psychological means. By doing so, they have positioned themselves in opposition to a strictly psychometric orientation, seeking instead to uncover a holistic picture of the individual.

Psychological diagnostics in the USSR developed primarily within the Leningrad School of Psychology under the guidance of B.G. Ananiev in the late 1960s. Ananiev defined psychodiagnostics as a research field focused on determining “the levels of development of psychophysiological functions, processes, states, and properties of the individual.” His approach included “establishing the structural features of each of these and their constellations that create complex behavioral syndromes” and “recognizing states of a person in response to various stimulators, stressors, frustrators, and complex situations.” Furthermore, he sought to determine “the potentials of human development (productivity, giftedness, special abilities, etc.).” Ananiev argued that “any mental process is formed as a certain constellation of psychophysiological functions (sensory, mnemonic, verbal, tonic, etc.), actions involving various operations (perceptual, mnemonic, logical, etc.), and motivations (needs, attitudes, interests, and value orientations).”

V.I. Voitko and Yu.Z. Hilbukh (1976) emphasized the necessary orientation of diagnostic practices toward personality research, noting two key points: “Firstly, psychodiagnostic research always has personality as its subject. Secondly, psychodiagnostics does not simply deal with individual persons—it engages only with those individuals whose behavior and activity are already known to exhibit certain deviations, shortcomings, and so on.”

K.M. Gurevich and E.M. Borisov (1981, 1993) examined psychodiagnostics as a discipline concerned with classifying individuals by specific criteria and uncovering the peculiarities of the human psyche. One of the authors emphasized: “People have various individual-psychological traits. How the laws of psychology manifest in the psyche of a specific individual is determined by their individual characteristics. Therefore, it is necessary to study these traits to predict how people behave in various life circumstances and whether their manifestations will differ.” The authors observe that psychodiagnostics, traditionally defined as the science of ranking individuals by measurable traits, has shifted significantly toward humanization.

This definition aligns with the proposition that the laws of psychology and individual-psychological traits are inseparable, functioning as a unity of the general, particular, and singular, as well as the theoretical and practical. Equally significant is the methodological assertion that diagnosis and prediction are inherently unified, both in the temporal progression from past to future and in the processual relationship between states and their subsequent transformations.

L.F. Burlachuk provided a successful generalization of his predecessors’ work: “Psychodiagnostics is a domain of psychological science that develops the theory, principles, and instruments for the assessment and measurement of individual-psychological traits of personality.” In this definition, Burlachuk reconciles the theoretical and practical dimensions of diagnosis by grounding the assessment of traits in established principles and scientific theory.

A. Anastasi and S. Urbina emphasize these same aspects in their foundational work on psychological testing, a primary methodology of psychodiagnostics. They note: “The use of tests in individual counseling has gradually expanded from narrow recommendations regarding educational and professional plans to encompass all aspects of an individual’s life. Emotional well-being and effective interpersonal relationships increasingly stand out as goals of counseling.” They observe a growing trend toward using tests to enhance self-understanding and personal growth, noting that “within this application of tests, their indicators form part of the information on which a person bases decisions about themselves and their life.” While tests are now employed to address a wide array of practical problems, the authors caution that “such tests are also an important means of fundamental research.”

These developments characterize the humanization and expansion of psychodiagnostics, particularly in the context of the relationship between the individual and the organization. This reflects a holistic system of relations—to oneself, the objective world, others, and social institutions. Furthermore, the synthesis of the theoretical and practical, and the fundamental and applied nature of diagnostic research, substantiates the core characteristics of social diagnosis.

The Dialectics of Problems and Perspectives

It is from this perspective that we examine the subject of social diagnosis: the social problem. We will focus on the role of the problem in orienting diagnostic activities and shaping our comprehension of social reality. While the connection between ‘problem’ and ‘perspective’ has historically received insufficient attention in methodological contexts, the phrase ‘problems and perspectives’ has long been a staple of scientific research.

The etymology of the word ‘problem’ stems from the Greek problēma, meaning task, obstacle, or difficulty. We can identify three significant aspects of this term.

  1. A problem characterizes the subject-object relationship, as its complexity necessitates additional effort from the subject, while an obstacle represents an external hindrance.
  2. A problem, as a task, relates to either theoretical or practical, productive or cognitive activities.
  3. The semantic weight of the term is closely associated with concepts of movement, development, and dynamics.

Contemporary scientific literature offers several competing definitions of a problem. First, a problem is frequently equated with a question. In this context, it is defined as “a theoretical or practical question that requires resolution or investigation.” A broader interpretation describes it “as a concept that expresses a question that objectively arises in the course of cognitive development, or a complex of questions whose resolution holds significant practical or theoretical interest.”

Second, a problem is defined as “a contradictory situation that presents itself in the form of opposing positions regarding the explanation of any phenomena, objects, or processes, necessitating an adequate theory for its resolution.” Finally, a problem is characterized “as a critical divergence between desired and actual states, which serves as a catalyst for the subject’s efforts.”

These definitions suggest two distinct approaches to understanding a problem. The first treats the problem as a situation where established goals remain unachieved. The second treats the problem as a latent opportunity.

The first approach reduces the problem to an epistemological dimension, narrowing it to a question or a conscious lack of information. By excluding the conditions and requirements of the problem, this definition remains incomplete. Without defining these conditions, one cannot ascertain the content of the question itself, and different questions may arise from the same problem. Furthermore, a problem remains illusory and unresolved without the subject’s concrete efforts. Thus, defining a problem merely as a question fails to capture its full essence.

An alternative approach understands a problem as a task. Any task comprises three essential elements: the conditions, which determine the causal relationships within the problematic situation; the requirements, which reflect the necessity of aligning the current state with the desired one; and the questions, which express the information gap. Resolving these questions either clarifies the conditions or leads directly to the solution. In this framework, the epistemological aspect is paramount, as the solution depends on verifying the scientific facts that define the pathways to success.

The second approach, which focuses on opposing epistemological positions, also narrows the concept of the problem by relegating its ontological aspects to the background. An ontological dimension is essential: the obstacle to achieving a goal exists objectively, as does the subject who confronts it. The ontology of a problem reflects the developmental process of the problematic situation or the subject within it. This ontological definiteness underpins the epistemological and praxeological aspects. V.S. Yukayeva defines the internal structure of the problem as a synthesis of the subject, the object, the connections between them, and the goal of the resolution. Epistemological and praxeological aspects are thus inseparably linked; knowledge and activity are intertwined in the act of problem-solving. The definition of the object and subject establishes the conditions of the task. The resolution of the main question constitutes a process of goal-setting—an activity focused on choosing the alternatives and means required to navigate the problematic situation.

A third perspective examines the problem through the dialectics of possibility and reality, or the ‘actual’ versus the ‘desired’. On one hand, a problem manifests the dynamic transition from possibility to reality, encompassing both the current state and the envisioned future. On the other hand, it emerges from causal relationships where unresolved issues generate new problems, fueled by both existing conditions and the subject’s inaction. This framework seeks to reconcile the significance of the real, objective state with the subjective, desired outcome.

I.V. Bestuzhev-Lada understood the problem as a rupture between the actual and the desired, emphasizing the distinction between a problematic state and a problematic situation. He stated: “A problematic state is one in which there objectively exists and is subjectively recognized by a person, social group, or society as a whole the necessity for significant changes to bring the actual and desired states as close as possible. Accordingly, a problematic situation is a collection of problematic states, a condition of affairs in a particular area overall, in which the indicated necessity emerges as an imperative complex for an individual, social group, or society as a whole, as a social phenomenon (a problem and problematic state may not necessarily be of a social nature).”

This distinction between possibility and problem is linked to the stages of formulating a prospective social problem. Following an analysis of the relationships within the initial model and the projected background, the process culminates in building a prognostic model. This final stage clarifies the features of future development for the research object in light of emerging trends, while abstracting from any potential intervention by the sphere of governance. In short, the framework extracts management possibilities directly from the prospective problem.

While we agree that possibilities and problems must be distinguished, we contend that possibilities should not be excised from the problem itself; they are, in fact, the very conditions of the problem. Choosing a solution is inherently a choice among conscious possibilities. The concept of the ‘measure’ of a problem remains underdeveloped when the gap between the actual and the desired becomes so vast that it threatens the normal functioning of a social object—what Bestuzhev-Lada calls a problematic situation. This analytical gap often stems from a failure to identify a ‘common denominator’ for the ‘desired’ within a polymorphic social world or from neglecting the axiological aspect of the problem. A problem may hold different values for different actors, raising the question of whether the ‘desired’ is merely an arbitrary whim or whether common grounds exist for these competing evaluative systems. We propose that a common denominator exists, defined by the ‘measure of life’ that constrains subject activity. The evaluative component is thus determined by the subject’s existence, implementation (becoming), and realization, as the ‘desired’ remains unattainable outside the subject’s specific measure of life. This framework applies equally to individual humans, social groups, and society as a whole, provided they are granted the significance of integrity and life.

Current perspectives on the problem converge on the dialectic of possibility and reality, or the tension between the actual and the desired. The problem marks the dynamic transition from possibility to reality, encompassing both current conditions and future aspirations. Furthermore, it arises from causal chains where unresolved issues generate new problems, fueled by both existing conditions and the subject’s inaction. In this framework, the problem is essentially a rupture between the actual and the desired; when the latter is not limited by the possible, the problem becomes illusory and untethered from reality.

This definition reflects four essential aspects. In the ontological aspect, the rupture manifests as complexity. The epistemological aspect frames it as a task. The praxeological aspect finds it in the unity of subject, object, connections, and the goal of resolution, where the rupture itself becomes the focus of subject activity. Finally, the axiological aspect distinguishes the problematic from the non-problematic. While one of these dimensions may dominate, the problem is most fully understood when these aspects are considered together, as resolving fundamental questions necessarily transforms the subject’s worldview and social perspective.

The social perspective defines the developmental dynamics of the specific domain to which the subject’s activity is oriented. It must be grounded in prospective problems that emerge from a rigorous scientific analysis of ontological, epistemological, praxeological, and axiological aspects. In the context of Ukrainian society, this unity forms the triad of life: existence, implementation, and the realization of achievements. When any single aspect is distorted during analysis, the resolution of the problem suffers accordingly. The absence of this triadic foundation in social life reduces existence to an absurd closed circle of living merely for the sake of living.

By defining the problem, the social subject clarifies the objective foundations of the social perspective—those conditions changing independently of human will. Simultaneously, it identifies the subjective meaning, which encompasses the requirements and ideals contingent upon human activity and cognition. To divorce the social perspective from this dialectical interplay between the objective and the subjective is to render systematic investigation impossible. Ignoring the subjective dimension leads to determinism and fatalism, which diminishes subject activity by imposing an external measure of life—whether attributed to God, chaos, fate, or some distant future. Conversely, disregarding the objective dimension fosters voluntarism and a false sense of impunity, restricting the measure of life solely to internal characteristics. Because the measure of life reveals itself only in relationships, it must be examined through the dialectical tension between these subjective and objective aspects. The emergence of social problems thus reflects the broader or narrower context of social being in its developmental dynamics, a field where social work finds both its application and its scientific exploration.

As a distinct form of social activity, social work maintains a pronounced focus on individuals and their social status, which in turn provides the foundation for its idealization. The contradiction inherent in the social perspective as the measure of life manifests directly as the need for social work, encompassing assistance, services, processes, programs, and institutional systems. Serving as a mechanism for solving social problems, social work must address the societal phenomena generated by underlying social contradictions. A problem in this domain signifies the practical activity required to resolve a problematic situation arising from objective necessity. Contemporary social work conceptualizes the social perspective through an interaction model designed to stimulate the personal development of the subject and secure the socialization of individuals. This approach reinforces the ideological dimension while reflecting the idealization of social work itself.

Everyday Diagnostic Practices and Metaphors

The measure of life establishes social diagnosis as both a theoretically conscious activity and a socio-cultural practice of everyday life passed down across generations. In a broad sense, social diagnosis is the capacity and set of tools for recognition. In a narrower sense, it is the process of identifying the situation, behavior, and activity of an individual, social group, or society through the use of diagnostic metaphors in daily practice. This process operates at multiple levels of human cognition. At the theoretical level, it functions as an explicit technology of problem recognition; at the mundane level, it appears as everyday diagnostic practices of figurative recognition.

Everyday diagnostic practices function as a natural manifestation of anticipatory reflection that underpins both forecasting and communication. Transmitted across generations, these practices become stereotyped, evolve, and spread throughout socio-cultural communities as practically oriented identifications and evaluations that shape decision-making and social behavior. Lacking the artificial, technological armature and theoretically conceived algorithmic principles of formal science, these practices remain metaphorical in nature, relying on recognition without strictly codified scholarly procedures. At the root of these metaphorical practices lie the principles of similarity and likeness, deployed either consciously or spontaneously.

The primary diagnostic metaphors include the images of boundaries, norms, social pathology, advancement, dispositions, reconnaissance, patterns, and investigations.

The imagery of ‘boundaries’ and ‘norms’ concerns how we distribute and evaluate normative standards versus extreme states. If the norm represents the ideal, then diagnosis seeks to harmonize conditions, identifying possibilities for timely intervention to prevent the system from reaching an extreme state that might cause irreversible damage. Conversely, if development is deemed the optimum, we explore the qualitative shifts the norm undergoes as it transitions through those extremes. In this view, development requires us to account for the internal reserves of a social organism, limiting advancement to what the system can resourcefully sustain. This dialectical unity between the optimal state and the process of development allows for an approach to harmonious growth. It accounts for both the compatibility of system components and the coherence of the system’s current state with its trajectory.

Pathology and Mapping as Diagnostic Metaphors

The metaphor of social pathology emerges directly from our understanding of norms, treating pathology as a disease that compromises the integrity of the social organism by distorting its normal state. Two distinct approaches arise from this perspective. The ‘paramedical’ or symptomatic approach relies on established diagnostic procedures governed by a simple symptom-to-treatment logic. The ‘medical’ or causal approach, by contrast, requires a systematic investigation that moves beyond general knowledge to identify the unique, specific elements inherent in any given problematic situation.

The image of ‘advancement’ links diagnostic practice to the art of cartography, drawing on the logic of topographic and bathymetric mapping. This metaphor finds expression in the concept of ‘dispositions’ and the military-topographic imagery of ‘reconnaissance.’ Both seek to gauge the balance of forces, available resources, and the likely outcomes of confrontations between competing parties. Similarly, planimetric mapping provides a framework for metaphors involving ‘paths,’ ‘networks,’ and ‘webs.’

Studying these locations—the interrelations between various entities—necessarily involves a range of structural-functional, causal, and field-based relationships. The process of unpacking such metaphors mirrors the fundamental operations of cartography. It requires establishing a ‘language of maps,’ surveying the ‘relief of the terrain,’ and developing the conventional symbols required to visualize specific problems and situations.

Metaphors of ‘patterns’ inform diagnostic practice through both conscious classification and the spontaneous, often unconscious, comparison of unfamiliar events or individuals against familiar archetypes.

The metaphor of ‘investigation’ relies on the imagery of reading and interpreting traces. This approach is primarily deductive, moving from the general to the particular—from an established understanding of causal relationships within a given field to the specific features of a concrete situation.

Social diagnosis is a goal-oriented activity of management subjects, objectified through diagnostic practices and social technologies disseminated within the socio-cultural space. As a social technology, it exhibits all the hallmarks of the craft: artificiality, repeatability, reproducibility, operability, a holistic orientation, and an internal, algorithmic logic.

Diagnosis, when framed as a technology, consists of the identification of a problematic situation; its problem-oriented nature provides the essential foundation for subsequent forecasting. This includes the formulation of multiple potential futures and the prioritization of future projects. Ultimately, this framework integrates design, which focuses activity on the future state of the object; planning, which provides that activity with spatiotemporal certainty; and management, which ensures the continuous, coherent execution of these endeavors.





Über den Autor

Dieser Artikel wurde von Sykalo Yevhen zusammengestellt und redigiert — Bildungsplattform-Manager mit über 12 Jahren Erfahrung in der Entwicklung methodischer Online-Projekte im Bereich Philosophie und Geisteswissenschaften.

Quellen und Methodik

Der Inhalt basiert auf akademischen Quellen in mehreren Sprachen — darunter ukrainische, russische und englische Universitätslehrbücher sowie wissenschaftliche Ausgaben zur Geschichte der Philosophie. Die Texte wurden aus den Originalquellen ins Deutsche übertragen und redaktionell bearbeitet. Alle Artikel werden vor der Veröffentlichung inhaltlich und didaktisch geprüft.

Zuletzt geändert: 15/11/2026