Protagoras - Pre-Socratics - Ancient Philosophy
History of Western Philosophy - 2024 Inhalt

Ancient Philosophy

Pre-Socratics

Protagoras

During the second half of the 5th century BCE, a skeptical movement emerged in opposition to the great pre-Socratic systems. The preeminent figure of this movement was Protagoras, the leader of the sophists. Initially, the term “sophist” carried no negative connotation; it was simply synonymous with “teacher.” A sophist was a professional who earned a living by imparting knowledge deemed beneficial for practical life. Because the state provided no public education, sophists taught only those with personal means or wealthy parents. This arrangement inevitably imbued the work of the sophists with a class bias. This condition was exacerbated by the political climate of the era. In Athens and many other Greek cities, democracy had triumphed, yet no measures were taken to redistribute the wealth of the old aristocratic families. These wealthy citizens were the primary embodiment of what we now recognize as Hellenic culture. They possessed the leisure for education, their travels softened their traditional prejudices, and their time spent in debate sharpened their intellect.

The Socio-Political Climate of Athenian Democracy

What was then termed democracy left the institution of slavery entirely untouched. Slavery allowed the affluent to enjoy their wealth without the need to oppress their fellow free citizens. Nevertheless, in many cities—Athens in particular—the poorer citizens harbored a double animosity toward the wealthy, stemming from both their economic dependency and historical tradition. The rich were often suspected, sometimes justifiably, of impiety and immorality, of undermining ancient beliefs, and even of plotting to dismantle democracy itself. Thus, in the cultural sphere, political democracy became curiously intertwined with conservatism, while those who championed cultural innovation leaned toward political reaction.

A somewhat similar situation exists in contemporary America, where “Tammany Hall” represents a political organization originally created to defend traditional theological and ethical dogmas against the encroachments of enlightenment. However, the enlightened in America are politically weaker than their Athenian counterparts, as they have failed to align themselves with the plutocracy. Nonetheless, there exists in America a significant and highly intellectual class interested in protecting the interests of the wealthy: the corporate legal class. In some respects, the functions of this class are analogous to those performed by the sophists in Athens.

Athenian democracy, despite its significant limitations in excluding slaves and women, was in certain respects more participatory than any modern system. Judges and most executive officials were chosen by lot and served for short terms. Consequently, much like our jurors, they remained average citizens who lacked professional training and carried the biases typical of the middle class. In Athens, cases were generally heard by a large number of judges. Plaintiffs and defendants appeared in person, representing themselves rather than relying on professional lawyers. Naturally, the success or failure of a case depended heavily on oratory skills and the ability to appeal to popular prejudices. While individuals were required to deliver their own speeches, they could hire specialists to compose them or, as many preferred, pay for instruction in the cunning required to succeed in court. It was widely believed that the sophists taught these very arts.

The Age of Pericles parallels the Victorian era in English history. Athens was a wealthy, prosperous city, not yet overly troubled by external conflict. It enjoyed a democratic system under the governance of aristocrats. As previously observed in relation to Anaxagoras, the democratic opposition to Pericles gradually gained strength, and his supporters were targeted one by one. The Peloponnesian War broke out in 431 BCE. Athens, alongside many other regions of Greece, was ravaged by plague. The population, which had reached 230,000, significantly dwindled and never returned to its former levels.

Pericles himself was removed from command in 430 BCE and fined by the court for the illegal appropriation of public funds, though he was soon reinstated. His two sons perished from the plague, and in the following year, 429 BCE, he himself died. Phidias and Anaxagoras were condemned. Aspasia was also prosecuted for impiety and maintaining a house of ill repute, though she was ultimately acquitted.

In such a society, it was natural for those facing the hostility of democratic politicians to seek out legal training. For Athens, despite its penchant for persecution, was in one respect more liberal than contemporary America: those accused of impiety and corrupting the youth were at least allowed to defend themselves. This explains the popularity of the sophists among one class and their unpopularity among another. Yet, in their own estimation, the sophists served impartial ends, and it is undoubtedly true that many of them were genuinely committed to philosophy. Plato devoted his efforts to caricaturing and discrediting them, but one should not judge the sophists solely by his polemics. Consider, in a lighter vein, the following excerpt from Plato’s dialogue “Euthydemus,” where two sophists, Dionysiodorus and Euthydemus, attempt to confuse a simple man named Ctesippus:

Public Perception and the Sophist Movement

“Tell me, do you have a dog?” asked the interlocutor. “Yes, and a very fierce one,” replied Ctesippus. “Does she have puppies?” “Yes, also fierce.” “And their father, surely, is also a dog?” “I have even seen him mating with the female.” “Well then, this dog is yours?” “Of course.” “Then this father is yours, thus your father is a dog, and you are the brother of the puppies.”

In a more serious vein, consider the dialogue titled “Sophist.” It presents a logical discussion regarding definition, using the term “sophist” as an illustration. Currently, we are not concerned with the logic of this discussion, but I wish to quote its concluding statement:

“This name denotes a hypocritical imitation of an art based on opinion, which entangles another in contradictions,” states the dialogue. It is an imitation belonging to the art of representation, which conjures phantoms and distinguishes in its creations not the divine but the human aspect of trickery. “Whoever considers a complete sophist to arise from this flesh and blood would seem to express himself quite justly,” the text concludes.

A well-known anecdote about Protagoras—undoubtedly apocryphal—illustrates how the sophists were perceived by the public in relation to the courts. It is said that Protagoras taught a young man on the condition that the latter would pay for his instruction only upon winning his first trial. However, the young man’s first trial was instigated by Protagoras himself, in a calculated move to collect his fee.

Yet it is time to leave these preliminary remarks and examine what is actually known about Protagoras.

The Life and Philosophy of Protagoras

Protagoras was born around 500 BCE in Abdera, the city from which Democritus hailed. He visited Athens twice, the second visit occurring no later than 432 BCE, and he drafted a code of laws for the city of Phuria in 444-443 BCE. While tradition holds that Protagoras faced legal persecution for impiety, this is seemingly untrue. He did, however, write a book titled “On the Gods.” The work began with this assertion: “Concerning the gods, I cannot know whether they exist or not, or what they are like in appearance. For there are many obstacles to knowledge—the obscurity of the matter and the brevity of human life.”

His second visit to Athens is satirically depicted in Plato’s Protagoras, while his teachings are more seriously explored in Theaetetus. Protagoras is primarily known for his doctrine that “Man is the measure of all things—of things that are, that they are, and of things that are not, that they are not.” This doctrine suggests that each individual serves as the measure of all things; when people differ, there exists no objective truth that renders one correct and the other incorrect. Essentially, this is a skeptical doctrine, apparently grounded in the inherent deceptiveness of the senses.

One of the three founders of pragmatism, Ferdinand Schiller, often referred to himself as a disciple of Protagoras. This is likely because Plato, in his Theaetetus, asserted—while interpreting Protagoras—that one opinion may be superior to another, even if it cannot be truer. For instance, when a person suffers from jaundice, everything appears yellow. It is futile to claim that things are not truly yellow but are instead colored as a healthy person perceives them. However, we can assert that since health is preferable to sickness, the opinion of the healthy person is superior to that of the jaundiced individual. This perspective is clearly akin to pragmatism.

For practical purposes, disbelief in objective truth makes the majority the arbiters of what ought to be believed. Consequently, Protagoras defended law, custom, and traditional morality. Although, as we have seen, he was uncertain about the existence of gods, he was convinced that they deserved worship. This viewpoint is evidently valid for a person whose theoretical skepticism remains consistent and logical.

Professional Teaching and Intellectual Independence

Protagoras spent his mature life on a continuous lecturing tour across the cities of Greece, teaching for a fee anyone who yearned for practical success and higher spiritual culture. Plato protested against the sophists’ practice of charging for education, partly from a position of snobbery by modern standards. Plato himself possessed ample resources and thus appeared unable to comprehend the needs of those lacking financial means. It is curious that contemporary professors, who see no reason to forgo salaries, often echo Plato’s accusations against the sophists.

There is, however, another point in which the sophists differ from most contemporary philosophers. Typically, each teacher—excluding the sophists—established a school that exhibited certain characteristics of brotherhood, often featuring degrees of communal living that resembled monastic life and generally espousing an esoteric doctrine not proclaimed to the public. All this was natural where philosophy arose from Orphism, but among the sophists, there was nothing akin to this. What they taught was not, in their view, connected to religion or morality. They taught the art of debate and provided as much knowledge as was necessary for that purpose. Generally speaking, they could, much like modern lawyers, demonstrate how to defend or contest a given opinion without caring to defend their own conclusions. Those for whom philosophy served as a guide in life, intimately tied to religion, were naturally shocked; to them, the sophists appeared frivolous and immoral.

To some extent, the hatred the sophists elicited from the general public and from Plato and his successors was rooted in their intellectual honesty. One cannot ascertain the precise weight of this circumstance. The pursuit of truth, when sincerely undertaken, must remain indifferent to moral considerations. We cannot know in advance how the truth will align with what a given society deems instructive. The sophists were willing to follow the evidence wherever it might lead, which often brought them to skepticism. One sophist, Gorgias, claimed that nothing exists. He argued that if anything does exist, it is unknowable, and even if something exists and is knowable to one person, that individual cannot convey their knowledge to others. We do not know the specific arguments Gorgias employed, but one can imagine they possessed a logical rigor that compelled his opponents to seek refuge in dogma. Plato always endeavored to promote views he believed would lead people to virtue. He was rarely intellectually honest, as he consistently evaluated doctrines based on their social utility. Even in this, he lacked candor, for he pretended to follow arguments and judge by purely theoretical criteria while actually steering the debate toward a predetermined virtuous outcome. Plato introduced this vice into philosophy, where it has persisted ever since. The character of his dialogues is defined by his hostility toward the sophists. A chronic shortcoming of philosophers since Plato has been the tendency to conduct ethical investigations while assuming the conclusions they are meant to reach.

Moral Relativism and Political Power

In Athens, at the close of the fifth century BCE, some individuals taught political doctrines that appeared immoral to their contemporaries. These ideas remain just as unsettling to democratic nations today. In the first book of Plato’s Republic, Thrasymachus argues that justice is nothing more than the interest of the stronger. He contends that laws are created by governments for their own benefit and that no objective criteria exist to measure conduct in the struggle for power. Callicles, according to Plato in Gorgias, advocated a similar doctrine. He argued that the law of nature is the law of the stronger, but that for the sake of convenience, humans established institutions and moral precepts to restrain the strong. While such doctrines are more widely disseminated today than they were in antiquity, they were not, regardless of how they are perceived, characteristic of the sophists.

The Peloponnesian War and the Decline of Athens

During the fifth century BCE, independent of the role the sophists played, Athens underwent a transformation. It shifted from a state of rigid, puritan simplicity to one of witty and often cruel cynicism, struggling against the dull, brutal resistance of a waning orthodoxy. The beginning of the century was marked by the Athenian defense of the Ionian cities against the Persians and the victory at Marathon in 490 BCE. By the end of the century, in 404 BCE, Athens suffered defeat at the hands of Sparta. In 399 BCE, Socrates was executed. After this, Athens lost its political significance, yet it gained an undeniable cultural preeminence that lasted until the rise of Christianity.

Certain circumstances in the history of Athens during the fifth century BCE are crucial for understanding Plato and all subsequent Greek thought. During the first Persian War, glory came to Athens primarily through its decisive victory at Marathon. Ten years later, during the second Persian War, Athens maintained its naval preeminence among the Greeks, but on land, victories were largely attributed to the Spartans—the recognized military leaders of the Hellenic world. However, the Spartans held narrow, provincial views; they ceased fighting the Persians as soon as the latter were expelled from European Greece. The defense of the Asian Greeks and the liberation of the islands conquered by the Persians were successfully undertaken by Athens. As a result, Athens emerged as the leading naval power and established strong imperial control over the Ionian islands. They thrived under the rule of Pericles, a moderate democrat and a moderate imperialist. The grand temples, whose ruins still recall the glory of Athens, were erected under his auspices to replace those destroyed by Xerxes. The city grew rapidly in wealth and cultural sophistication. As often occurs in such eras, especially when wealth is derived from external trade, traditional morality and beliefs fell into decline.

During this time, Athens was home to an extraordinarily large number of brilliant individuals. Three great playwrights—Aeschylus, Sophocles, and Euripides—all belonged to the fifth century BCE. Aeschylus participated in the battle of Marathon and witnessed the conflict at Salamis. Sophocles remained orthodox in his religious views, whereas Euripides was influenced by Protagoras and the spirit of free thought; his interpretations of myths were skeptical and deconstructive. Aristophanes, the comedic poet, mocked Socrates, the sophists, and philosophers in general, yet he belonged to their circle. In Plato’s Symposium, he is depicted as being on very friendly terms with Socrates. The sculptor Phidias, as we have seen, was also associated with the circle of Pericles.

During this period, the superiority of Athens was more artistic than intellectual. Except for Socrates, none of the great mathematicians and philosophers of the fifth century BCE were native Athenians. As for Socrates, he was not a writer and confined himself to oral discussions.

The outbreak of the Peloponnesian War in 431 BCE and the death of Pericles in 429 BCE ushered in a dark chapter of Athenian history. While Athens maintained naval supremacy, the Spartans held the advantage on land, repeatedly invading Attica during the summer months—though they never breached the walls of Athens itself. Consequently, the city became dangerously overcrowded with refugees, and its population suffered the ravages of a devastating plague. In 414 BCE, the Athenians dispatched a major expedition to Sicily to capture Syracuse, an ally of Sparta; the campaign ended in total failure. This prolonged conflict hardened the Athenian spirit, breeding cruelty and vengeance. In 416 BCE, they seized the island of Melos, executed all able-bodied men, and enslaved the remaining inhabitants. Euripides protested against such barbarity in his play The Women of Troy.

The conflict also possessed an ideological dimension: Sparta championed oligarchy, while Athens stood for democracy. Paranoia festered among the Athenians, who began to suspect their own aristocrats of treachery—a suspicion many believed contributed to the eventual maritime defeat of Athens at the Battle of Aegospotami in 405 BCE.

By the end of the war, the Spartans imposed an oligarchic regime in Athens known as the ‘Thirty Tyrants.’ Some of these men, including their leader Critias, were former students of Socrates. They were deservedly unpopular, and within a year, they were overthrown. With Spartan consent, democracy was restored, though it remained a bitter and resentful system. An amnesty prevented the proponents of democracy from openly seeking retribution against their internal foes, yet they seized every opportunity to circumvent its terms and pursue their enemies. It was within this volatile atmosphere that Socrates was condemned and executed in 399 BCE.





Über den Autor

Dieser Artikel wurde von Sykalo Yevhen zusammengestellt und redigiert — Bildungsplattform-Manager mit über 12 Jahren Erfahrung in der Entwicklung methodischer Online-Projekte im Bereich Philosophie und Geisteswissenschaften.

Quellen und Methodik

Der Inhalt basiert auf akademischen Quellen in mehreren Sprachen — darunter ukrainische, russische und englische Universitätslehrbücher sowie wissenschaftliche Ausgaben zur Geschichte der Philosophie. Die Texte wurden aus den Originalquellen ins Deutsche übertragen und redaktionell bearbeitet. Alle Artikel werden vor der Veröffentlichung inhaltlich und didaktisch geprüft.

Zuletzt geändert: 15/11/2026