Completion of Natural Philosophical Concepts in Cosmology: The Teachings of Empedocles and Anaxagoras
As we transition from early Greek philosophy to the classical period (5th–4th centuries BCE), we witness the culmination of natural philosophy, marked by the infusion of metaphysical concepts into its framework. This synthesis of natural philosophical and metaphysical ideas became a defining feature of several schools, most notably those of Empedocles, Anaxagoras, and Democritus.
Empedocles was a citizen of Acragas in Sicily, living approximately from 490 to 430 BCE. His cosmological doctrine is encapsulated in his poem “On Nature,” of which fragments survive. This work reveals one version of the complex of ideas that Greek natural philosophy ultimately embraced.
Empedocles posited that the world’s fundamental constituents are the four classical elements: earth, water, air, and fire. He referred to these as ‘roots’ (ῥίζαι) of all things:
“Equal in power are the elements from which everything we now see was born: Earth, the turbulent Sea, moist Air, and Titan Ether, which encompasses the whole world.”
Sources also suggest that these elements are composed of smaller particles—elements of elements—that precede the four primary constituents. Empedocles identified these fundamental particles as ‘roots’ (ῥίζαι).
Mechanical Models of Change and Motion
The second key concept in the natural philosophy of Empedocles is the abandonment of the biomorphic model that formerly characterized the birth and death of things. Instead, he introduced a physical-mechanical model, where entities come into existence through the combination of elements and are destroyed through their separation. This framework explains his reliance on the four fundamental elements, for without them, there would be nothing to combine or separate. Furthermore, it is with Empedocles that fire, air, water, and earth are correctly designated as ‘elements’ and ‘principles’, as these terms denote the fundamental components from which all things are constructed.
This transition is evident in the way Empedocles revised the language of natural philosophy. He moved away from biomorphic terminology, replacing it with new descriptors. ‘Coming into being’ and ‘destruction’ are merely names for the mutual joining and disintegration of entities. As Empedocles states:
“Among all mortal things, none has birth… nor… an end from cursed death, but it is merely mixing and separating of mixed elements. People call this ‘birth’.”
Plutarch notes that Empedocles eliminates absolute creation and destruction, reducing them to the mere transition from non-being to being and back again.
Thus, things are mixtures of elements; however, this mixture is not mechanical in the sense of simple conjunction, but rather ‘chemical’, arising from the interaction and transformation of the elements themselves. Empedocles expresses this by stating that elements “pass through each other” and appear different due to their mixture. If elements did not change during this process, we would perceive only earth, water, air, and fire in isolation, which is not the case.
Love and Strife as Cosmic Forces
The concept of mixing elements necessitated the introduction of external forces to drive the process. This is the third fundamental tenet of the natural philosophy of Empedocles. According to the ancient worldview of hylomorphism and panpsychism, these forces reside within the emotional-psychic life of impulses: Love and Strife. Nonetheless, in the context of ancient materialism, these forces are physical. Empedocles describes Love as possessing a specific spatial extent. Aristotle observed that Empedocles, unlike his predecessors, divided the moving cause, establishing not one but two distinct and opposing principles.
What is the nature of these forces? The common feature of their action is that it is characterized by Necessity (ἀνάγκη) and persuasion. Each force acts in its own distinct manner: Love unites, while Strife separates:
“Under the action of Strife, all [elements] become diverse and separate. Under the action of Love, they come together and desire each other.”
The relation of these forces to the elements is defined by their positioning: Love is present within the elements, while Strife is external to them. Moreover, these forces move and alter their positions in space through their actions. One fragment mentions that as elements came together, Strife retreated to the outermost edge. The predominance of one force over the other alternates, governed by Necessity.
The universe of Empedocles is conceived as pulsating with the rhythm of a heartbeat: Love is systole, the contraction of elements into one; Strife is diastole, the expansion of elements into many. Empedocles describes this rhythm:
“At times, through the action of Love, they come together into One, and at other times, under the fierce Strife, they scatter each in its own direction. Thus, the One grows to be the only thing from the many, then again splits to become many from the One, Fire, Water, Earth, and the immeasurable height of Ether.”
What does this process entail, and what are its fundamental aspects? Based on the surviving fragments, the sequence is as follows: the initial state of the elements is their unity within the One. The division of the One and the subsequent formation of the many constitute their coming into being. This position reveals the One as an abstract primal matter that later manifests as concrete forms, confirming earlier interpretations of the One by Parmenides and the One-and-All by Melissus as a substance. Subsequently, under the influence of Love, the elements coalesce into a unified cosmic structure, only for the cosmos to emerge and be destroyed anew as the One breaks apart; this alternation is eternal.
The two phases of the cosmic process—the One and the Many—can be viewed as two distinct modes of being in the Eleatic spirit. The One, as the Sphere (Sphairos) or God, is unified, immobile, and intelligible; the Many is the cosmos, which is mobile and sensibly perceivable. Thus, the doctrine of Empedocles integrates the metaphysical and physical levels of existence, revealing the perpetual oscillation between rest and movement.
The Pulsating Cosmos of One and Many
Let us consider the two states of the cosmos. Empedocles posited Love as the creative principle of the intelligible cosmos, uniting elements into the Sphere (Sphairos). In the Sphairos, things become One and are therefore devoid of quality: neither fire nor any other element retains its individuality or inherent form. In this ‘surrounding repose of the proud Sphairos,’ one cannot discern the sun, the earth, or the sea, as the Sphairos is equal to itself from every side. The Sphairos is not merely a metaphysical formation but a divine one. In describing it, Empedocles, much like Xenophanes, attempts to distance himself from conventional anthropomorphic depictions of the deity; the Sphairos-God has no hands, shoulders, knees, feet, or reproductive parts.
The creative principle of the sensible cosmos is Strife, which forms the world through the disjunction of elements. This occurs when Strife prevails, inciting movement within the Sphairos; the elements separate and, once dispersed, form a mixture—this is the cosmos.
The pair of the One (Sphairos) and the Many (the cosmos) can be viewed as a unit or a single phase of infinite cosmic movement, which consists of an endless alternation of such pairs. The One serves as the beginning of the phase, while the Many marks its completion. The transition from the One to the Many results in the cosmos. Empedocles explains the origin of the cosmos from the primary state as an unmoved mixture. As one fragment notes, he omits the cosmogony during the Age of Love because the cosmos consists of already separated elements and must therefore arise from undivided unity.
In greater detail, the formation of the cosmos proceeds as follows: from the initial mixture of elements, air emerges and spreads around the mixture in the form of a sphere. Following the air, fire bursts forth and positions itself beneath the sky. The separation of the roots leads to their becoming parts of the visible world: earth, sea, sky, and sun. This marks the period of inanimate nature. The appearance of living nature completes the formation of the cosmos from elements, which, as Empedocles states, includes everything that was, is, and will be: trees, men, women, beasts, birds, fish, and enduring gods. The elements mixed to form humans, wild beasts, trees, and birds. Here, the elements may be interpreted as natural forces whose interaction generates plants and living beings.
Biological Evolution and Sensory Perception
The formation of living nature occurs in several stages. According to Empedocles, the first generations of animals and plants were not whole but divided into unsorted parts. Initially, from a kind of pregnant earth, individual limbs—heads, hands, legs, eyes—emerged. These separate parts of the first animals were born during the Age of Love. Strife, by separating the elements, created inanimate nature. Love, by combining them, initiated living nature and continues to act within its framework by fostering the union of separate members into living beings.
In the early stages of this cosmogony, the limbs of various creatures were joined in haphazard combinations. Empedocles describes these phantom-like beings as “monstrous… with twisted legs and dismembered hands,” “bull-like with human heads,” and “two-faced and two-breasted.” These mismatched parts failed to form a functional whole. Consequently, they could not survive and perished, marking a failed experiment in the development of living generations.
In another phase, the members of beings of the same kind joined together to create a complete nature. For example, a human head joining with a human body maintained its wholeness. Such formations became the third generation of properly born beings. These creatures were able to survive, became animals, and sustained themselves through the mutual satisfaction of needs:
- teeth cut and grind food
- the stomach digests it
- the liver transforms it into blood.
The third generation gave rise to the fourth generation of animals and plants. These were distinguished by the fact that living beings were born not from elements like earth and water but from one another. Plants accumulated excess food, and the beauty of female animals induced a spermatic movement. Animals separated due to the varying composition of their mixtures. Those more related to water gravitated toward it, while others ascended into the air. Heavier ones settled on the earth, and those with evenly mixed elements throughout their bodies developed speech.
Empedocles’ natural philosophy, particularly in its later biological phase, stands as a significant milestone in the history of science, reflecting a shift typical of ancient thinkers. In his philosophical conclusions, Empedocles abandoned divine explanations for the origin of living beings, opting instead for purely natural causes. He also rejected teleology in this context, suggesting that viable organisms emerge by chance through a process of trial and error. Because of this, Empedocles is often regarded as a distant precursor to the Darwinian theory of evolution and natural selection.
Empedocles also proposed a theory of sensory perception based on emanations (ἀκτίνες), which travel from objects to penetrate the pores of the senses—a view later adopted by other philosophers.
Empedocles posited that all things coming into existence emit emanations. These are evident in the reflections seen in mirrors or the lingering presence of odors. Dogs, for instance, lose the scent of a dead rabbit because the fragrance can no longer detach from the skin, ceasing entirely with the animal’s death. Odors are, in essence, qualities or substances—particles shed by their original source. This theory is captured in the observations that “the scent is the remnants of animal parts” and that “dogs pick up emanations left by animals in the forest.”
This concept of emanations likely represents an early attempt to identify the psycho-physiological mechanism of perception. Before Empedocles, philosophers had merely acknowledged the existence of sensory and rational knowledge; he was the first to suggest that sensory knowledge depends on an external influence acting upon the sensory organs.
Empedocles holds a significant place in the evolution of Greek philosophy, representing one of its two primary trajectories. It is important to remember, however, that his work also contains a substantial religious and moral dimension, as evidenced by the fragments of his poem, “Purifications.”
Anaxagoras and the Theory of Seeds
Another approach to natural philosophy, which posited that the world is created from specific elements through a particular force, was proposed by Anaxagoras of Clazomenae (c. 500–428 BCE). He lived in Athens during the era of Cimon and Pericles but was eventually forced to leave after being accused of impiety for claiming the sun was a hot rock rather than a deity. He spent his final years in Lampsacus. Anaxagoras is often credited with introducing philosophy to mainland Greece and Athens, though his original writings have been lost, leaving only fragments.
Anaxagoras proposed that the primary substances of the world are countless, infinitely divisible particles he called “seeds.” These seeds are microscopic likenesses of the objects they compose, reflecting a microcosm-macrocosm relationship. Aristotle referred to this characteristic as homeomeria (from ὁμοῖος, similar, and μέρος, part), denoting that a part is similar to the whole. In this view, homeomerias serve as the material models of all things.
Because seeds resemble the things formed from them, they must possess all the qualities and properties—both apparent and hidden—of those things. Anaxagoras famously claimed that “snow is black,” arguing that because snow melts into water under the sun, it must contain the potential for darkness. As Aristotle noted, “any particle is a mixture similar to the whole, as it is evident that any thing arises from any particle.” Anaxagoras established the principle that both seeds and objects contain a universal set of qualities, expressed in the maxims “everything contains a part of everything” and “everything is contained in everything.” This suggests a world of universal connections where every element is interrelated. As Simplicius observed, “nothing exists separately; everything participates in everything.” No axe can separate the warm from the cold, for every thing is related to all others and contains a multitude of qualities.
Despite this, every object remains qualitatively defined by its specific properties. Simplicius explains this by noting that a thing is dominated by a particular group of homogeneous homeomerias: “Each thing is characterized by what predominates in it. Thus, something appears golden if it contains a lot of gold, even though it contains everything.” Therefore, the qualitative definiteness of an object results from the quantitative predominance of certain seeds.
Under this framework, things arise from the simple aggregation of seeds, making the whole a sum of its parts. The Roman poet Lucretius noted that bones arise from tiny bones, and so on. Like Empedocles, Anaxagoras concluded that there is no true creation or destruction, only the combination and separation of homeomerias. Changes in the world are merely shifts in the quantitative ratios of these seeds. For Anaxagoras, there are no genuine qualitative transformations, only quantitative increases or decreases in the number of homeomerias; he thus adheres to a principle of quantitativeness.
In his commentary on Anaxagoras, A. S. Bogomolov highlights that, according to this doctrine, nothing is ever truly new; rather, development is simply the growth of what already existed. This theory of preformation suggests that if a bone arises from pieces of bone, then a raven arises from a tiny raven.
Anaxagoras’ theory of homeomerias provided a framework to explain both physical phenomena, such as the transformation of white snow into black, and biological processes, specifically how food becomes part of the human body. He argued: “We consume simple and homogeneous food—bread and water—and this nourishes hair, veins, arteries, flesh, muscles, bones, and other body parts… It must be agreed that the food we consume contains everything that exists.” As Simplicius observes, Anaxagoras maintained that “in food and water, if consumed by trees, there is wood, bark, and fruit.” Food sustains our organs because it contains particles similar to those organs; otherwise, as Anaxagoras insisted, a logical contradiction would arise: hair could not come from non-hair, nor meat from non-meat.
The Role of Nous in Cosmic Order
The combination and separation of homeomerias, the formation of the cosmos, and the changes in things occur through a special external force—mind (νοῦς). Ancient authors explain that Anaxagoras considered homeomerias as matter, while mind was the active principle that organized everything. Cicero writes that Anaxagoras was the first to teach that the forms and images of all things are composed by the power and wisdom of an infinite intellect. For this reason, Anaxagoras was referred to as "Mind."
Nous initiated contact with the initial mixture of homeomerias, triggering a circular motion or whirlwind that led to the formation of ether and air. Anaxagoras stated that “at the beginning, bodies were stationary; but the divine mind brought them into order and caused the emergence of the Universe.” It appears that his doctrine of the supremacy of Nous and the cosmic whirlwind was widely known in Athens, where it was perceived as undermining the power of Zeus. This sentiment is reflected in Aristophanes’ Clouds, which contains numerous lamentations on the subject. For example:
“Zeus is already retired, and now the whirlwind governs the universe.”
In summary, the world was formed as follows: from the whirlwind emerged air, which condensed into clouds, then water, and finally earth. Plants and animals originated from seeds dispersed in the air and carried to the ground by rain. As Theophrastus attests: “Anaxagoras says that air contains the seeds of everything, which are carried down by rain and generate plants.”
Nous serves as the source and cause of the movement of homeomerias. Consequently, it was understood in antiquity not as a psychic force, but as a physical, material one—a point for which Anaxagoras was frequently criticized. Plotinus wrote that “Anaxagoras… destroys the mind he introduces, not considering it as form or idea, and posits it not before matter but simultaneously with it.” Simplicius notes that Nous is “the subtlest and purest of all things.” I. D. Rozhansky’s monograph on Anaxagoras summarizes these perspectives. He concludes that Nous performs two functions: it provides the primary impulse that causes particles to rotate, and it acts as the highest law governing cosmic formation. The term Nous was thus developed to denote objective regularity; in it, one can discern a rational law of being, much like the Logos of Heraclitus.
The foundations of Anaxagoras’ philosophy place him alongside Empedocles. His theory of nature incorporates a metaphysical component through the concept of homeomerias. As infinitely divisible particles, these seeds exist beyond the reach of sensory perception. Furthermore, Anaxagoras posits that cosmic matter is transformed into the world by an external force: Nous. This signifies a transition from a biomorphic model of cosmogony to a physical-mechanical one. As A. S. Bogomolov suggests, Anaxagoras rejects the ancient view of physis—a self-generating and self-moving nature—as the ultimate source of all generation.
Über den Autor
Dieser Artikel wurde von Sykalo Yevhen zusammengestellt und redigiert — Bildungsplattform-Manager mit über 12 Jahren Erfahrung in der Entwicklung methodischer Online-Projekte im Bereich Philosophie und Geisteswissenschaften.
Quellen und Methodik
Der Inhalt basiert auf akademischen Quellen in mehreren Sprachen — darunter ukrainische, russische und englische Universitätslehrbücher sowie wissenschaftliche Ausgaben zur Geschichte der Philosophie. Die Texte wurden aus den Originalquellen ins Deutsche übertragen und redaktionell bearbeitet. Alle Artikel werden vor der Veröffentlichung inhaltlich und didaktisch geprüft.
Zuletzt geändert: 15/11/2026