The Philosophical Approach to The Understanding of Man - The Problem of Man in Philosophy
Social Philosophy - 2024 Inhalt

The Problem of Man in Philosophy

The Philosophical Approach to The Understanding of Man

The understanding of man is the central problem of philosophy, echoed in the words of Socrates and later by H. Skovoroda: “Know thyself.” The human desire to comprehend one’s own nature serves as a fundamental impetus for the development of philosophical thought.

In contemporary science, there are more than 800 disciplines studying humanity, yet each examines it from specific, partial angles. Philosophy, however, is concerned with what is most fundamental and definitive in humanity, the essence upon which the unity of all aspects of human existence rests.

Each individual embodies universal traits inherent to all humans as members of a single species. They also carry socially typical characteristics specific to their concrete society, people, class, or nation, alongside individual traits that create the unique identity of a person. All these attributes are organically interconnected. On one hand, the individual’s peculiarities represent a specific manifestation and amalgamation of the socially typical and universal human traits. On the other hand, species nature cannot exist otherwise than as it is manifested in individual human beings living in particular temporal and social contexts. For philosophy, the primary significance lies in understanding the general species-being of humanity, which provides the key to grasping individual differences and the changes that occur throughout human history.

Among the eternal philosophical problems surrounding the comprehension of the species nature of humanity, which shape the anthropological direction of philosophical reflections, one encounters fundamental questions. What is man in general, and what is his nature or essence? The resolution of each of these issues necessitates the formulation and clarification of numerous inquiries. Answers to these depend on the development of accumulated scientific and philosophical knowledge, shaped by specific historical conditions, as well as the prevailing worldview and value orientations in society.

The Historical Separation of Philosophical and Scientific Anthropology

The anthropological theme was long—from ancient times until the 17th and 18th centuries—defined solely within the domain of philosophical inquiry. The term “anthropology” (from the Greek meaning “human”) was first introduced by Aristotle to designate that branch of philosophy that studies humanity.

The advancement of the natural sciences in the modern era led to the human organism becoming a subject of scientific inquiry. From the 17th century onward, scholars studying the physical structure of the human body began using the term “anthropology” to refer to this field of natural scientific research. In the 19th and 20th centuries, anthropology gained the status of an independent science concerning the natural history and biological structure of humans. It branched into two main areas: paleoanthropology, which studies historical remnants of human forms, anthropogenesis, and raciogenesis; and the study of modern forms of humanity.

However, the establishment of anthropology as a distinct scientific discipline did not remove the problem of humanity from the domain of philosophy, as natural scientific anthropology neither poses nor resolves philosophical questions. Moreover, the philosophy of man remains one of the central themes in philosophy. In the 18th century, Helvetius and La Mettrie dedicated their principal works to it. Kant asserted that anthropology, or the study of man, is simultaneously a worldview, since humanity is “the most significant subject in the world.” He considered the question “what is man” to be the most important query of his entire philosophical framework, believing that anthropology should provide the answer.

Feuerbach founded his teaching on the anthropological principle, setting himself the task of creating a philosophy of man, that is, anthropology. For him, the idea of man was both the starting point and the ultimate goal of philosophy. Feuerbach’s anthropologism spurred the development of philosophical investigations into the essence and nature of humanity.

Following Feuerbach, the anthropological tradition in philosophy was further developed from a materialist perspective by K. Marx and F. Engels. In a different ideological spirit, this tradition found expression in the works of F. Nietzsche, S. Kierkegaard, W. Dilthey, and others.

The 20th-Century Emergence of Philosophical Anthropology

In the 20th century, philosophical thought made yet another anthropological breakthrough. Thanks to the work of a group of German scholars—M. Scheler, H. Plessner, A. Gehlen, E. Rothacker, M. Landmann, among others—and biologists A. Portmann and K. Lorenz, an intellectual current emerged that synthesized the results of both natural scientific and humanities studies of humanity. This current is known as philosophical anthropology. Its proponents believe that a philosophical understanding of the essence of humanity should serve as the foundation of all philosophy, as the mystery of the world is embedded within man.

According to Scheler, philosophical anthropology should integrate three distinct circles of conceptions about humanity that intersect in the consciousness of contemporary Europeans. The first is the Judeo-Christian conception of humanity as created by God, marked by the fall of Adam and Eve and ideals of righteous living. Antiquity contributed a second view of humanity as a distinct rational being coexisting with the gods. Modern science provided a third conception, in which humanity appears as a product of animal evolution, yet differs from other organisms in the degree of its vital organization. However, these circles exist independently of one another, portraying fragmented images of humanity. From this disconnect arises the absence of a unified idea of humanity, the formulation of which remains the primary task of philosophical anthropology.

Attempts to articulate a singular idea of humanity that would define its essence have persisted throughout the history of philosophy. While the ancient Greeks regarded reason as the defining attribute of humanity, Christianity placed faith above reason. Descartes maintained that the fundamental property of humanity is the capacity to think (“I think, therefore I am”), whereas Kant asserted that the essence of humanity as a thinking individual finds expression in the moral law that elevates humanity above the animal world. In the 18th century, the French philosopher J. La Mettrie argued that humanity is far more than an “animated machine,” whereas the American thinker B. Franklin defined humanity as a tool-making being. Furthermore, the foundational conditions of human existence have been identified as will (A. Schopenhauer), labor (K. Marx), freedom (J.-P. Sartre), communication (K. Jaspers), language (M. Heidegger), and play (J. Huizinga), among others…

A critical examination of these various concepts reveals the difficulty of reducing the question of human nature to a single paramount characteristic that constitutes a person as such. Nonetheless, synthesizing the global history of scientific and philosophical thought allows us to distinguish three orientations that shape the primary approaches to this question.

Core Orientations in Defining Human Essence

In philosophical thought from antiquity through the 18th century, one prominent orientation treated the soul as the internal essence of humanity. The human body was regarded merely as the garment of the soul (Aristotle), while the true essence of humanity was associated with its spirituality. Although the soul was understood in various ways, it was consistently viewed in unity with consciousness and reason, which were seen as the essential traits of humanity.

Classical German philosophy of the 18th and 19th centuries proposed and substantiated the idea that human distinctiveness is determined not only by spirituality and rationality, but also by the capacity for active, free agency. Within this capacity lies the ultimate manifestation of human rationality. Expanding on this insight, Marx and Engels concluded that practical activity plays a foundational role in the formation and development of humanity and humankind.

In dialectical-materialist philosophy, another crucial aspect of the anthropological characterization of humanity came to light: humanity is not only a rational living being, but one formed exclusively within social and cultural conditions. Humanity possesses a dual, biosocial nature. It exhibits characteristics that, on one hand, belong to it as a biological species, and on the other hand, emerge and transform through societal development. In this respect, biological traits serve merely as the starting conditions for a specific way of life that unfolds as a person participates in society, which produces and embodies culture. For this reason, the social and cultural conditioning of human existence remains central to many contemporary philosophical concepts of humanity.

Thus, the historical development of anthropological thought has established three fundamental principles that characterize the species-being of humanity: spirituality, activity, and sociality. These principles define the core of the philosophical understanding of humanity and continue to command recognition in contemporary discussions of the issue.





Über den Autor

Dieser Artikel wurde von Sykalo Yevhen zusammengestellt und redigiert — Bildungsplattform-Manager mit über 12 Jahren Erfahrung in der Entwicklung methodischer Online-Projekte im Bereich Philosophie und Geisteswissenschaften.

Quellen und Methodik

Der Inhalt basiert auf akademischen Quellen in mehreren Sprachen — darunter ukrainische, russische und englische Universitätslehrbücher sowie wissenschaftliche Ausgaben zur Geschichte der Philosophie. Die Texte wurden aus den Originalquellen ins Deutsche übertragen und redaktionell bearbeitet. Alle Artikel werden vor der Veröffentlichung inhaltlich und didaktisch geprüft.

Zuletzt geändert: 15/11/2026