Animatedness - The Essence of Man - The Problem of Man in Philosophy
Social Philosophy - 2024 Inhalt

The Problem of Man in Philosophy

The Essence of Man

Animatedness

Animateness is the philosophical and scientific understanding of the relationship between the human body and soul, tracing its evolution from religious anthropology to contemporary psychophysical theories. Even in early societies, humans distinguished between the body and the soul. The human body is a unique material entity that requires specific environmental conditions, such as a stable chemical composition and temperature, to survive. Like other living organisms, humans have basic bodily needs that must be met to sustain life. Securing these material conditions is the natural right of humanity as a biological being. Yet, unlike any other organism, humanity is not merely biological, for human bodily life is intimately linked to the life of the soul.

Traditionally, the concept of the soul has been viewed as a special force residing within the human body. In mythological thought, human traits were projected onto inanimate objects, which were likewise endowed with a soul. This gave rise to the earliest polytheistic religions, which posited the existence of many gods who resembled humans while remaining immortal and far more powerful.

The evolution of religious consciousness transformed the understanding of the relationship between humanity and the divine. Humans created gods in their own likeness and subsequently believed those gods had created humanity in His.

The human soul and God are genetically linked concepts. At the foundation of the religious worldview lies the idea of a fundamental similarity between humanity and the cosmos. Just as humanity possesses a dual nature, the universe features a visible, material body alongside an invisible, immaterial soul—often called the world soul, the world spirit, the higher spiritual substance, or God. Just as the human body is flesh of the world’s flesh, the human soul is a fragment of the divine spirit bestowed upon humans at birth as a divine gift.

Attempts to comprehend human existence from these perspectives give rise to religious anthropology, in which humanity is considered a creation of God. Understanding humanity is thus framed as a matter of grasping the divine plan.

The soul is the central category of religious anthropology, defined by its immateriality, immortality, and capacity to exist independently of the body. The human body lives only as long as the soul resides within it; the separation of the immortal soul from the body marks the end of earthly existence. Various traditions answer the question of the soul’s subsequent fate differently. It may wander the world in a bodiless state, reincarnate into other bodies, merge with the world soul, or transition to another destination such as heaven, hell, or purgatory.

According to Christian belief, the purpose and meaning of human life are tied to observing God’s commandments, with eternal heavenly bliss serving as the reward. Saving the soul from sin, preserving its purity, and striving for its perfection constitute the primary concerns of earthly life, even though the soul remains imperiled by sinful desires.

The human body and its flesh are frequently regarded as the source of sin. This view gives rise to the ascetic preaching common to many religions, which exhorts believers to subdue bodily passions and abstain from carnal pleasures.

An alternative perspective holds that God endows the soul with free will, requiring it to choose between virtue and vice. If the soul chooses evil, it does so through its own corruption, meaning the source of sin lies within the soul itself.

Both viewpoints depict human life as an arena of constant struggle between the soul and the body. The precise relationship between soul and body remains a question that religious anthropology has never satisfactorily answered.

The Scientific Transition from Soul to Psyche

To advance our understanding of humanity, its body, and its soul, we must move beyond religious-scholastic reflections. We must adopt scientific methods for studying reality, making both body and soul subjects of empirical investigation and theoretical generalization.

As a material object open to direct observation, the human body has long been studied by numerous sciences, including anatomy, physiology, anthropology, anthropometry, and medicine. Science understands that the human body consists of the same atoms and elementary particles as any other natural object, and that its cells, tissues, and organs share deep similarities with those of other animals. The life of the human body adheres strictly to the natural laws established by physics, chemistry, biology, and related disciplines.

The soul, however, is a far more complex matter. In scientific terms, it cannot be studied by invoking God or supernatural forces, but must instead be understood entirely through earthly processes operating according to natural laws.

The roots of this scientific approach can be traced to ancient notions of the soul as a discrete body housed within the human form that departs at the moment of death. Even so, early thinkers struggled to conceive of spirit as entirely incorporeal.

In ancient Eastern philosophy, the human soul was understood as the vital spirit, circulating like a fluid through the channels within the body’s organs. The heart was regarded as its center. Ancient materialist philosophers advancing atomic theory, such as Democritus, believed the soul to be a special organ of the human body composed of fire atoms—spherical, very small, and mobile. The physician Alcmaeon, who discovered the nerves connecting the eye to the brain, proposed the idea of the brain as the seat of the soul. The renowned ancient Greek physician Hippocrates believed the soul was formed from a fine ethereal substance present in the air, known as pneuma, that enters the brain through respiration.

The Greek word psyche, meaning soul, has entered European philosophy and science from ancient tradition. It gave rise to the term psychology, which began to denote phenomena and processes related to the soul.

However, it was not until the 18th century that the problem of the soul was articulated as an issue of empirical natural research on the psyche. Different mental processes, states, and personal attributes were identified and subsequently described and analyzed in detail. The science of the psyche became known as psychology, a term that emerged in the 18th century in place of pneumatics, which had previously designated the science of the soul. Nevertheless, in the 18th and 19th centuries, psychology was considered a philosophical science, a branch of philosophy. It was only at the end of the 19th century that psychology separated from philosophy and gained status as an independent science, a transition associated with the name of Wilhelm Wundt.

In contemporary scientific psychology, the concept of the soul has yielded to the concept of the psyche. Thus, some scholars express the opinion that, since the concept of the soul is unscientific, there is no soul at all. However, such a judgment is not entirely correct and bears more stylistic weight than substantive significance. How then are the problems concerning the soul approached and resolved in contemporary science?

Three aspects can be distinguished within which the soul is described:

  • the structure or composition of the soul, meaning the various types of mental phenomena—desires, feelings, experiences, sensations, thought processes, knowledge, and so on—which constitutes the structural aspect
  • the content of human spiritual life, that is, the specific individual complex of desires, emotions, experiences, and thoughts that fills the soul of the individual and grants them a unique and distinctive spiritual face, forming the content aspect
  • the nature of the soul, comprising its origin and the substrate or substance from which it is formed, known as the genetic or substrate aspect

The primary focus of scientific-psychological research has been the structural aspect of the soul. This is what has come to be known as the psyche. The psyche thus represents the soul in its structural aspect. Consequently, the concept of the psyche encompasses only a portion of the concept of the soul, and thus it is not identical to the latter.

The content aspect of the soul refers to what is objectively implied by the term the spiritual world of the individual. Within the context of this aspect, the spiritual world of the individual is contingent not only upon the psyche. Its content is determined by:

  • the social life in which the individual is immersed
  • the cultural state of society
  • the real possibilities for that individual to engage with cultural values

The spiritual world of the individual constitutes a domain that is the subject of analysis in philosophy and various humanities, including ethics, aesthetics, and cultural studies. It also forms the primary subject of the arts.

Materialist Perspectives on Mental Phenomena

From a genetic standpoint, animateness receives its essential definition by way of its relationship to the broader reality from which it emerges and within which it dwells. As noted earlier, two distinct traditions attempt to define the essence of the soul: 1) the soul arises as an offshoot of a higher, supernatural spiritual substance; 2) the soul is generated by specific configurations of matter to form a distinct material entity. Wilhelm Wundt characterizes the first approach as spiritualistic and the second as materialistic. Yet cast in this light, the second view reflects not materialism as a whole, but rather a naive, vulgar, and naturalistic materialism.

Developed forms of materialist philosophy do not assert that the soul consists of matter. The soul is immaterial; however, as the psyche or the spiritual world of the individual, it exists within humanity due to material processes occurring within its nervous system. In other words, ultimately, the soul is dependent on, and derivative of, matter. The materialist understanding of the psyche corresponds with contemporary scientific approaches to its study.

The Mind-Body Problem in Contemporary Philosophy

In this regard, the question of the relationship between mental and physiological phenomena becomes significantly important, constituting the mind-body problem, or more narrowly the psychophysiological problem. The existence of connections between processes occurring in a person’s psyche and physiological processes observed in their nervous system is indisputable. However, the essence of the problem lies in explaining the mechanism of such a connection. After all, mental phenomena such as images, thoughts, and desires are immaterial and lack physical properties. They possess neither the substance nor the energy necessary to exert force on physical bodies. At the same time, they induce material physical, chemical, and physiological changes in our bodies. How then does thought influence the body?

René Descartes first posed this question in the 17th century, proposing an early version of the concept of psychophysical interaction. According to Descartes, mental phenomena—consciousness, thought, and will—and bodily phenomena, such as muscular movement or changes in nerve cells, belong to two fundamentally different orders. Bodily phenomena relate to material substance, while mental phenomena pertain to the spiritual. Material substance possesses spatial extension, whereas the spiritual is non-spatial. Consequently, Descartes argued that material and spiritual processes cannot influence one another, though he maintained that a specific site, the pineal gland, serves as a point of contact enabling their interaction.

An alternative, the concept of psychophysical parallelism, was proposed by Leibniz and others who argued that interaction between spirit and matter is fundamentally impossible. This view asserts that while there is no causal connection between mental and physiological phenomena, correspondence and coherence between them remain possible. Mental and physical processes unfold in parallel, or synchronously. Leibniz maintained that the correspondence between them is established through a ‘pre-established harmony,’ the author of which is, of course, God.

Both concepts interpret the mental and physical in a dualistic spirit, treating them as two independent substances that exist separately. This dualism hinders any true understanding of the connection between psyche and body. Many contemporary philosophers and scholars propose other pathways for resolving the mind-body problem. Some attempt to ‘materialize’ thoughts, equating them entirely with brain processes and attributing physical-energy characteristics to them (H. Feigl). Others posit a special ‘spiritual energy’ that creates an ‘influence field’ of thought, which can ‘activate’ neurophysiological processes in the brain (J. Eccles). Yet, endowing thoughts with physical energy effectively treats them as material formations rather than ideal ones. If thoughts possess a unique spiritual energy, it remains unclear how such energy, lacking physical properties, can induce changes in nerve cells.

To this day, no solution to the mind-body problem has gained universal recognition. Among the various directions of inquiry, the informational approach is one of the most promising. This view considers mental processes as the acquisition, storage, transmission, and transformation of information, while physiological—or neurodynamic—processes serve as the material carriers of this information, acting as the signals in which it is encoded. From the perspective of the informational approach, the ability of thought to influence bodily processes is explained by the fact that thought always has a material carrier: a corresponding neurodynamic system. The influence of thought on the body constitutes informational control. Thought does not govern the body independently; rather, it acts through the neurophysiological processes that serve as its material carriers.

Thus, materialism does not deny the existence of the soul; it does not assert that the soul is material, but speaks only of its dependence on the body. Unlike religion, it rejects the belief in the existence of the soul outside the body or in its immortality. The only immortality lies in the memories of the deceased and their deeds, not in their individual souls. Animateness is not a mystical quality but a function of these complex material systems.





Über den Autor

Dieser Artikel wurde von Sykalo Yevhen zusammengestellt und redigiert — Bildungsplattform-Manager mit über 12 Jahren Erfahrung in der Entwicklung methodischer Online-Projekte im Bereich Philosophie und Geisteswissenschaften.

Quellen und Methodik

Der Inhalt basiert auf akademischen Quellen in mehreren Sprachen — darunter ukrainische, russische und englische Universitätslehrbücher sowie wissenschaftliche Ausgaben zur Geschichte der Philosophie. Die Texte wurden aus den Originalquellen ins Deutsche übertragen und redaktionell bearbeitet. Alle Artikel werden vor der Veröffentlichung inhaltlich und didaktisch geprüft.

Zuletzt geändert: 15/11/2026