Unity and Diversity of The Socio-Historical Process - Society
Social Philosophy - 2024 Inhalt

Society

Unity and Diversity of The Socio-Historical Process

The question of unity and diversity within the socio-historical process remains a central concern in social philosophy and the philosophy of history. Its resolution involves addressing the dialectic of the general and the particular in historical progression, as well as the relationship between the specific-historical and the universal-human. One of the earliest thinkers to attempt a comprehensive understanding of this unity and diversity was the 17th-18th century Italian philosopher Giambattista Vico. His work served as a precursor to future theories of cyclical development in cultures and civilizations. Unlike the classical Enlightenment approach, Vico examined the dynamics of what might be termed a naturalistic social idealism. According to this view, the geographical environment exerts its influence primarily at the moment a people’s spiritual composition is formed. The true driving force of historical development, in all its diversity, is instead the ‘spirit of the people’ shaped by that environment. From this perspective, Vico linked social progress to the development of a national essence, viewing folk customs and moral guidelines as genuine expressions of humanity’s ‘social nature.’ However, because Vico’s conception lacks a principle of historicism, he concluded that all social organisms and cultures in world history are equally valid. They ultimately lack a broader historical perspective and are thus doomed to inevitable decay.

Early Methodological Frameworks in Social Philosophy

Throughout the 18th and the first half of the 19th centuries, the philosophy of societal development was primarily oriented toward two methodological frameworks. The first was naturalism, appearing either as geographical determinism—as seen in the work of Montesquieu, K. Ritter, Bockh, G. Herder, and L.I. Mechnikov—or as idealistic naturalism, represented by K.A. Helvetius and J.J. Rousseau. The second framework was objective idealism, championed by thinkers such as I. Kant and G. Hegel.

Naturalism is a school of social philosophy grounded in the methods and conclusions of the natural sciences. Within this framework, the laws discovered in the natural sciences are typically transposed onto society and regarded as universal principles for explaining all social processes.

The methodological basis of geographical determinism is materialist monism. Particularly in its early stages, this approach posits the geographical environment as the primary factor in the evolution of any specific society, as well as in the socio-historical development of humanity as a whole. In doing so, it relegates psychological and cultural elements to a secondary role. Nevertheless, it acknowledges that at higher stages of civilization, rational factors gradually gain prominence.

Idealistic naturalism begins with the thesis of nature’s primacy and the ‘natural state’ of humanity, wherein all individuals were equal and free, living in conditions suited to their nature. By focusing on humanity’s capacity for improvement, this theory substantiates the extraordinary role of rational factors in shaping the development of the individual and the entire system of social relations—including institutions of private property, power, and the state—as expressed in the theory of the social contract. This ultimately leads to a dualistic doctrine that posits the eternal coexistence of the corporeal and the spiritual within nature.

Objective idealist concepts of history are based on the assumption that an objectively existing spiritual factor drives the development of humanity and specific societies. Within various conceptual frameworks, this factor may be identified as the Logos, God, the Absolute Idea, Absolute Reason, or the Absolute Will.

The Formation Approach to Historical Development

From the second half of the 19th century onward, social philosophy has frequently employed both the formation approach and the civilizational approach to examine the historical development of humanity.

The formation approach was established within Marxist philosophy, where K. Marx and F. Engels first articulated the fundamental principles of formation analysis and developed a corresponding system of categories, including socio-economic formation, base, superstructure, mode of production, productive forces, and relations of production. This approach belongs to the classical, linear tradition, whose general principles are also characteristic of G. Hegel’s philosophy of history. Like Hegel’s system, it relies on a monistic, universalist understanding of history. However, while Hegel interprets universal history as a singularly linear process of the development of the Absolute Spirit, the formation approach views it as a natural-historical process defined by the sequential transformation of socio-economic formations.

The term ‘formation’ was borrowed by Marx from geology, likely from three sources: his own studies in geology; Hegel’s ‘Philosophy of Nature’; and Dureau de la Malle’s ‘Political Economy of the Romans,’ where a similar concept is utilized. In the context of human history, the notion of ‘formation’ encompasses two dimensions: society as a process and society as a state, defined by the structure of relations among individuals. The term ‘socio-economic formation’ aligns with the Marxist dialectical-materialist concept, which considers the material factor paramount in the development of all aspects of social life. In this view, society is an integrated system of relations in which productive relations play the determining role.

Marx and Engels never formally defined the term “socio-economic formation.” Instead, they utilized it as a working concept to address specific cognitive or practical questions when analyzing social processes. In Marxist literature, however, a socio-economic formation is generally understood as a historically specific type of society grounded in a particular mode of production and serving as a stage in the progressive development of world history.

The formation approach posits that all history consists of the successive transformation of socio-economic formations. Yet, this classification faces significant challenges, as it is objectively impossible to force the diverse national and historical forms of social organization into a single, unified schema. While Soviet sociological literature traditionally distinguished five socio-economic formations—primitive communal, slave-owning, feudal, capitalist, and communist—the founders of Marxism provided no such rigid taxonomy. K. Marx often applied the term “socio-economic formation” to bourgeois society, yet he never used it to describe primitive society, preferring the term “social formation” instead. Furthermore, when he referred to slave-owning, feudal, or communist societies as socio-economic formations, he did so only in direct juxtaposition to bourgeois society. Marx also introduced the “Asiatic mode of production” to account for the unique socio-economic relations observed in certain Asian nations.

The “five-member” classification of formations is currently met with considerable skepticism in scholarly circles. It relies on an oversimplified, linear view of history that implies an unwarranted uniformity in social systems and a tendency toward historical fatalism. Nevertheless, the formation approach retains its vitality by treating society as a complex system. It highlights the interaction between material and spiritual factors, securing its continued status as a viable theoretical model for interpreting linear socio-historical development.

The Civilizational Approach and Cultural Evolution

Another approach to understanding the development of human society is the so-called non-linear, non-classical civilizational approach. To grasp this perspective, it is essential to refer to the concept of civilization. Etymologically, the term “civilization” traces its roots back to Latin. It connects with such notions as “civiles” (civil), “civis” (citizen), and “civitas” (civil society). In its reinterpreted form, the concept of civilization entered scientific discourse in Western European countries, specifically France and England, from the mid-18th century. This emergence coincided with the vigorous advancement of capitalism and its establishment of benchmarks in the intellectual sphere. As a criterion for progress, the idea of social good, based on the primacy of reason, is affirmed. This idea allows individuals to negotiate with one another to ensure the protection of their interests, including life, security, freedom, and property. The social contract, according to J.J. Rousseau, conferred immense advantages to humanity. It guaranteed all the benefits of civilization, notably the development of industry, education, science, and more. However, civilization also entrenched economic inequality and political violence, leading to “barbarism”—the satisfaction of bodily needs, but not those of the spirit. Rousseau argued that only culture, through art and science, could meet the needs of the spirit. Thus, the concepts of “culture” and “civilization” were clearly delineated for the first time.

Civilization was envisioned as a necessary stage in the evolution of culture. Yet, it harbored sharp contradictions and threatened to turn into its own antithesis. It embodies the technological aspect of culture, emphasizing quantitative parameters of existence and the drive for limitless growth over qualitative depth. The essence of civilization lies in the perpetual transformation of technology to satisfy the incessantly rising needs and potentials of humanity, a process reinforced by legislative support.

This interpretation of civilization is largely rooted in the scientific and technological achievements of Western nations and the ideology of liberal democracy. By the early 20th century, however, many thinkers began to perceive a tragic disjunction between civilization and culture. M.Ya. Danilevsky, O. Spengler, and P. Sorokin candidly articulated a crisis of culture, describing a state in which life generates new forms of activity to which people are either unable to adapt or are artificially constrained by outdated social schemas.

In general, civilizations are viewed as specific historical manifestations of social life, which initially emerge as cultural-historical types and, upon reaching maturity, evolve into civilizations. Their lifespans do not align, differing both in developmental phases and temporal duration. During any given historical period, multiple civilizations may coexist in varying states of maturity, influence, and functional roles. Typically, however, one civilization is identified as defining the essence of the historical epoch. The classification of these civilizations varies significantly among thinkers. For instance, M. Danilevsky identifies ten cultural-historical types, arranged chronologically: 1) Egyptian; 2) Chinese; 3) Assyrian-Babylonian-Phoenician, Chaldean, or ancient Semitic; 4) Indian; 5) Iranian; 6) European; 7) Greek; 8) Roman; 9) Neo-Semitic or Arabian; and 10) German-Roman or European. In contrast, O. Spengler recognizes eight: 1) Chinese; 2) Babylonian; 3) Egyptian; 4) Classical (also referred to as Apollonian or Greco-Roman); 5) Arab (magical); 6) Western (Faustian); 7) Mayan culture; and 8) Russian. A. Toynbee counts over thirty civilizations throughout history, of which only six persist today: 1) Western; 2) Byzantine-Orthodox; 3) Russian-Orthodox; 4) Arab; 5) Indian; and 6) Far Eastern (Chinese, Japanese-Korean).

Engagement with the concept of civilization touches upon methodological issues concerning the foundational principles of the philosophical analysis of society within the broader historical process. From the perspective of contemporary interpretations of the civilizational approach, the historical process emerges not as a monolithic sequence but as a polycentric phenomenon involving the development and transformation of civilizations as cultural-historical forms. In this context, each civilization is perceived as a nonlinear entity of monadic nature.

This approach is shaped by the recognition that any living organism is not merely a singular entity. Instead, it presents itself as a multiplicity of autonomous beings, identical in essence yet diverse in manifestation. Civilization is therefore regarded as a unique monad of history. This monadic nature allows for a pluralistic understanding of the civilizational approach, helping to avoid one-sidedness and “centrism”—whether Eurocentric, Euro-Asian, Southern, or Northern. The modern civilizational approach is primarily concerned with examining civilizations as equivalent, albeit distinctive, expressions of humanity’s historical existence. Emphasizing the uniqueness and irreplaceability of historically significant entities allows us to view humanity’s collective history as a composite of the richness, diversity, and uniqueness of organized communities.

Consequently, the theory of developmental stages of society is historically limited. It was relevant to the era marked by the banner of scientific and technological progress (18th–19th centuries), reflecting the objective trends of that period. The civilizational approach, asserting itself in contemporary philosophy, meets the need for a more refined understanding of modern society. At its core lies the fact that humanity’s history has transformed into a global, universal narrative. Previously, history was defined by the experiences of distinct peoples, tribes, nations, regions, and cultures. The creation of a planetary civilization is a complex and often contentious process, which explains the increasing discourse surrounding the civilizational crisis of modernity. Sociology and philosophy have commonly divided history into periods of traditional (agrarian) civilization, technogenic (industrial) civilization, and a new, emerging phase, which some label post-industrial (informational).

The agrarian revolution, occurring 6,000 to 8,000 years ago, marked the transition from a consumer lifestyle to a productive one; the industrial revolution is associated with the emergence of machine production (16th–17th centuries); and the informational revolution, now reaching the most developed countries, marks the dawn of a new civilization.

The term “civilization” has many dimensions and lacks a singular, precise definition. At times, it is equated with “culture,” as when discussing Chinese, Sumerian, or Latin American civilization. Often, “civilization” denotes a higher level of societal development that succeeds an original state of barbarism and correlates with an advanced level of technique and technology. Nevertheless, the term is also used to characterize the entirety of material and spiritual human activity. In the context of the civilizational approach explored here, civilization is a specific historical formation, a branch of historical development, and a conglomeration of cultures and societies united by common traits.

Comparing Formations and Civilizations

How, then, do types of civilizations differ from types of socio-economic formations? Unlike the typology of formations, which is based on economic structures and specific production relations, the civilizational approach draws attention not only to the economic dimension but also to the entirety of societal life—material-economic, political, cultural, and moral. The foundation of civilization comprises not only its economic basis but, to a greater extent, a collective of cultural paradigms, value orientations, goals, motives, and ideals that shape certain psychological predispositions in people. Types of civilizations represent more global, stable entities than types of socio-economic formations. Within a single type of civilization, formative differences are possible. The development of civilization is a more potent, significant, and enduring process than the changes in formations. Each type of civilization possesses its own defining developmental factors and its unique mechanism of determination.

Traditional versus Technogenic Civilizations

Traditional civilization encompasses the periods of antiquity and the Middle Ages, including Ancient India and China, Ancient Egypt, and the states of the Muslim East. This type of social organization persists today, as many countries in the developing world still exhibit the characteristics of traditional societies. Such societies are defined by several specific traits:

  • an agrarian economic orientation
  • extensive, cyclical modes of development
  • a high degree of dependence on natural conditions, particularly geography
  • conservatism in their social relations and lifestyles

They maintain a high degree of dependence on natural conditions, particularly geography, and exhibit conservatism in their social relations and lifestyles. These societies prioritize the reproduction and preservation of the established order. Consequently, they often maintain a negative attitude toward innovation, instead favoring established norms, customs, and authority. This structure relies on strict social control and a high degree of dependence on collective groups, resulting in a marked limitation of individual freedom.

Technogenic civilization emerged from the remnants of medieval society. In this model, the extensive mode of social development gives way to an intensive one, where growth, renewal, and progress become the paramount principles of life. The cyclical mode of development transforms into a linear progression, and economic advancement—driven by science and technology—becomes the primary determinant of societal progress. A new value system emerges, rooted in science and technical expertise. The culture of technogenic civilization is centered on the transformation of the world and the subjugation of nature, placing a high premium on novelty and originality. The individual’s position also shifts fundamentally: the value of freedom is affirmed, equality is established regardless of social origin, and individual autonomy gains significance. Within this framework, the values of democracy, personal sovereignty, and the inviolability of individual rights become paramount. The primary orientation of individual activity shifts toward the achievement of success through personal effort.

Technogenic civilization is not only dynamic and mobile but also notably aggressive. It frequently suppresses and subjugates traditional societies and their cultures. This is not incidental, as the values of power, strength, struggle, and domination over natural and social circumstances are central to its ethos. Upon this foundation rests a cult of utility and a drive to possess goods, treating objects, human abilities, and information alike as commodities.

The evolution of Western societies in the 19th and 20th centuries has revealed a fundamental contradiction within technogenic civilization. On one hand, its ultimate goal—the increase of material wealth through the continuous renewal of technical-economic systems—risks reducing humanity to mere functionaries of the economic sphere. As the proportion of organized, rather than spontaneous, societal connections increases, spiritual production is transformed into a complex industry of consciousness. The individual becomes an object of manipulation by mass culture and media.

Conversely, technogenic civilization also champions individual freedom, mobilizes human activity, and stimulates the development of both needs and capacities, thereby fostering the humanization of a society founded on capitalist economics. In this way, technogenic civilization engenders both an economic foundation and a new type of human being capable of modifying and humanizing that foundation. This is evident in the development of economic and political liberalism, the recognition of social justice, the establishment of social protection mechanisms, the curbing of bourgeois power, and the protection of democratic freedoms. The superstructure, in defiance of formation theory, demonstrates an increasing capacity to gain independence from the economic base.

Future Trajectories of Global Civilization

Moreover, such a civilization will rest on a system of cultural values distinct from those of technogenic civilization. This system is based on the ethics of non-violence, a rejection of the cult of power, a tolerant attitude toward diverse cultural traditions, and fundamentally different principles governing humanity’s relationship with nature. The growing integrity and unity of humankind will be accompanied by an increase in the variability and diversity of cultural development.

Lastly, the new society will be built upon the evolution of a novel type of social connection. The society of fragmented, atomized individuals will transition to a society of free social communities, where individuals establish connections based on the principles of free choice, guided by their own tastes and needs.

In summary, the technological foundation of the future civilization will comprise fundamentally new processes and entities termed “synergetic,” signifying their capacity for self-development, such as computer systems and biotechnological complexes.

From the perspective of a civilizational approach—which is inherently nonlinear—historical progress does not merely advance along a straight line. Instead, it involves a series of revolutions, crises, and regressive shifts that lead to qualitative changes. The path of civilization is best understood through the lens of differentiation and integration, which generate various forms of development. Each subsequent stage of civilization transcends and integrates the accomplishments of its predecessors while simultaneously leading to a deeper and more complex integration of human existence.

The civilizational approach represents a contemporary, advanced lens for examining the complex processes of cultural and historical development. This approach seeks to illuminate the evolution of civilizations and their interactions, offering keen insights into humanity’s collective journey.





Über den Autor

Dieser Artikel wurde von Sykalo Yevhen zusammengestellt und redigiert — Bildungsplattform-Manager mit über 12 Jahren Erfahrung in der Entwicklung methodischer Online-Projekte im Bereich Philosophie und Geisteswissenschaften.

Quellen und Methodik

Der Inhalt basiert auf akademischen Quellen in mehreren Sprachen — darunter ukrainische, russische und englische Universitätslehrbücher sowie wissenschaftliche Ausgaben zur Geschichte der Philosophie. Die Texte wurden aus den Originalquellen ins Deutsche übertragen und redaktionell bearbeitet. Alle Artikel werden vor der Veröffentlichung inhaltlich und didaktisch geprüft.

Zuletzt geändert: 15/11/2026