John Scotus - Scholastics
History of Western Philosophy - 2024 Inhalt

Scholastics

John Scotus

John Scotus—often known by the epithet Eriugena—is perhaps the most remarkable figure of the ninth century. Had he lived in the fifth or even the fifteenth century, he would have astounded us less. An Irishman, a Neoplatonist, a brilliant connoisseur of Greek, a Pelagian, and a pantheist, John Scotus spent a significant portion of his life under the patronage of Charles the Bald, King of France. Although he did not adhere to orthodox views, he managed, as far as we know, to avoid persecution. He placed reason above faith and regarded the authority of the clergy as inconsequential; nevertheless, those same clerics turned to his esteemed opinion to resolve their disputes.

To understand the emergence of such a thinker, we must first examine the development of Irish culture in the centuries following the death of St. Patrick. Aside from the vexing fact that St. Patrick was an Englishman, we must note two other circumstances that are hardly less significant: first, that Christians existed in Ireland long before St. Patrick’s arrival; second, that whatever he may have accomplished for Irish Christianity, Irish culture owed him nothing. When Gaul fell victim to barbarian invasions—first under Attila and subsequently the Goths, Vandals, and Alaric—a Gallic writer recounted that “all learned men on this side of the sea fled, seeking refuge in the lands beyond the sea, particularly in Ireland, where they brought immense advancements in the sciences to the inhabitants.” If any of these scholars sought sanctuary in England, they met inevitable death at the hands of the Angles, Saxons, and Jutes. Those who fled to Ireland, however, succeeded in preserving a substantial part of the knowledge and civilization that had vanished from the continent. There are compelling reasons to believe that throughout the sixth, seventh, and eighth centuries, the Irish retained knowledge of the Greek language and maintained a solid acquaintance with the Latin classics.

In England, Greek had been known since the time of Theodore, the Archbishop of Canterbury (669–690), who was himself a Greek educated in Athens. In the north, knowledge of the language could also have been acquired through Irish missionaries. “By the end of the seventh century,” notes Montague James, “Ireland was a land that surpassed all others in its thirst for knowledge, with teaching flourishing abundantly. Latin (and to a lesser extent Greek) was studied from a scholarly perspective.” These scholarly refugees surged in crowds onto the continent, driven first by the fanaticism of missionaries and later by unsettling conditions at home. They played a significant role in preserving the remnants of literature they had come to value. Heiric of Auxerre described the influx of Irish scholars around 876: “Ireland, disregarding the perils of the sea, sends forth en masse a great multitude of philosophers to our shores, and all pillars of scholarship subject themselves to voluntary exile for the grace of the wise Solomon,” that is, King Charles the Bald.

Forced wandering has been the fate of scholars in many epochs. During the early period of Greek philosophy, many thinkers were fugitives from Persia, whereas in its latter period, they became refugees in Persia. In the fifth century, as we have seen, scholars fled from Gaul to the islands west of Scotland to escape the Germans. Ninth-century scholars fled from England and Ireland to escape the Scandinavians. Finally, in our own day, German philosophers are compelled to flee even further west to escape their own countrymen. One can only wonder how long it will take before they flee in the opposite direction.

We possess scant information about the Irish during the time they preserved the tradition of classical culture for Europe. This knowledge was tied to monasteries and thoroughly infused with piety, as evidenced by the rigorous penances of the Irish, though it is unlikely that it was deeply absorbed in theological subtleties. Centered primarily around monasteries rather than episcopal palaces, this learning remained free from the administrative spirit that characterized the continental clergy since the time of Gregory the Great. As the effective ties between this intellectual tradition and Rome were largely severed, it retained the perspective on the papacy that existed during the era of St. Ambrose, rather than the one that solidified later. Some believe that Pelagius was Irish, although he was most likely a Briton. It is entirely possible that his heresy survived in Ireland, where authorities could not eradicate it as they managed—albeit with difficulty—in Gaul. These circumstances partly explain the extraordinary freedom and freshness that characterize the theoretical views of John Scotus.

The beginning and end of John Scotus’s life remain unknown; we have information only about the middle period when he served the French king. It is generally believed that John Scotus was born around 800 and died around 877, but both dates are purely speculative. His time in France coincided with the papacy of Nicholas I, and in the biography of John Scotus, we again encounter the figures associated with this pope: Charles the Bald, Emperor Michael, and the pope himself.

Around 843, John was invited to France by Charles the Bald and appointed head of the court school. A dispute soon arose between the monk Gottschalk of Orbais and the influential Archbishop Hincmar of Reims regarding predestination and free will. The monk advocated for predestination, while the archbishop championed free will. John sided with the archbishop in his treatise “On Divine Predestination,” but in his defense, he ventured beyond the bounds of prudence. The topic was delicate; Augustine had addressed it in his writings against Pelagius, yet it was dangerous to agree with Augustine and even more perilous to openly oppose him. John defended the principle of free will—a stance that might have gone unpunished—but the purely philosophical nature of his arguments provoked outrage. This does not imply that John openly opposed established theology; rather, he asserted that philosophy is an authority equal or even superior to revelation, and independent of it. John insisted that reason and revelation are two sources of truth that cannot contradict one another; yet, he maintained that if they appear to be in conflict, reason should be given preference. “True religion,” John declares, “is also true philosophy,” and conversely, true philosophy is true religion. His work was condemned twice by church councils, in 855 and 859, the first of which dismissed it as “the nonsense of Scotus.”

John Scotus escaped punishment thanks to the support of the king, with whom he evidently shared a friendly rapport. If we are to believe the account of William of Malmesbury, on one occasion while dining with the king, John was asked, “What separates Scotus from the cattle?” to which John replied, “Only the width of the dining table.” In 877, the king died, and after this date, nothing is known of John. Some believe he died that same year. Legends suggest that Alfred the Great invited him to England, that he became the abbot of Malmesbury or Athelney, and that he was eventually killed by monks. However, it seems that this misfortune befell another John.

John’s subsequent work was a translation from the Greek of Pseudo-Dionysius the Areopagite. This work enjoyed immense acclaim during the early Middle Ages. When St. Paul preached in Athens, “some men joined and believed; among them was Dionysius the Areopagite” (Acts 17:34). This is all that is known of the man today, but in the Middle Ages, he was far better known. He was said to have traveled to France and founded the Abbey of Saint-Denis, or at least this is what Hildouin, who served as its abbot just before John’s arrival in France, asserted. Additionally, authorship of an important work aimed at reconciling Neoplatonism with Christianity was attributed to Dionysius. The date of its composition is unknown, though it was certainly written between the time of Plotinus and the fifth century. It was well known and esteemed in the East, but only a few in the West were aware of it until the Byzantine Emperor Michael sent a copy to Louis the Pious in 827, who passed it on to the aforementioned Abbot Hildouin. Hildouin, believing the text was indeed written by a disciple of St. Paul—the legendary founder of the abbey—was burning with curiosity to know its contents, but no one could translate it from the Greek until John appeared. John’s translation must have brought him true joy, as his own views were remarkably close to those of Pseudo-Dionysius; from this time onward, the latter exerted significant influence on the development of Catholic philosophy in the West.

In 860, John’s translation was sent to Pope Nicholas. The Pope was enraged that the work had been published without prior permission and commanded Charles the Bald to send John to Rome—a command that went unheeded. As for the content, particularly the scholarly expertise displayed in the translation, the Pope found nothing to critique. His librarian, Anastasius, a brilliant expert in the Greek language to whom the Pope entrusted the translation for review, was astonished that a man from a distant and barbarous land could possess such knowledge of Greek.

John’s most significant work was titled On the Division of Nature (Periphyseon). This book represents what would have been classified as ‘realism’ during the scholastic era, asserting, in accordance with Platonic doctrine, that universals exist prior to particular things. In his concept of ‘nature,’ John encompasses not only what exists but also what does not exist. All nature is divided into four kinds:

  • 1) creating but uncreated,
  • 2) creating and simultaneously created,
  • 3) created but not creating,
  • 4) neither creating nor created.

The first nature is clearly God. The second nature comprises the (Platonic) ideas that exist in God. The third nature consists of things that exist in space and time. The fourth nature unexpectedly returns to God, not as creator, but as the end and goal of all things. Everything that owes its existence to God strives to return to Him; thus, the end of all things coincides with their beginning. The connecting link between the one and the many is the Logos.

John includes various entities in the category of non-being, such as physical objects that fall outside the intelligible world and sin, which represents the loss of the divine image. Strictly speaking, only the creating but uncreated nature exists; it is the essence of all things. God is the beginning, middle, and end of all that is. Because God’s essence is unknowable to humans and angels alike, it is in a certain sense unknowable even to Himself. As John writes, “God does not know of Himself that He is, as He is not something; in a certain respect, He is incomprehensible neither to Himself nor to anyone’s reason.” Nevertheless, God’s being is discernible in the being of all things, His wisdom is visible in their order, and His life is revealed through their motion. His being is the Father, His wisdom is the Son, and His life is the Holy Spirit. Yet, Pseudo-Dionysius the Areopagite is correct to assert that no definitions can be applied to God. While a positive theology exists in which God is defined by categories such as truth, goodness, and existence, these definitions serve only as symbols. They are true only in a qualified sense, for these predicates imply their own negation, whereas God possesses no such opposing qualities.

The category of things that create and are simultaneously created encompasses all first causes, or archetypes, which are often identified as Platonic ideas. The totality of these causes constitutes the Logos. Although the world of ideas is eternal, it is nonetheless created. Under the influence of the Holy Spirit, these first causes give rise to the world of individual things, whose materiality is ultimately illusory. When it is said that God created things from “nothing,” this “nothing” must be understood as God Himself—in the sense that He is transcendent to all human understanding.

The process of creation is eternal, for the substance of all finite things is God. Creation is not a reality distinct from God; rather, it exists in Him, and He manifests Himself through it in an ineffable manner. “The Holy Trinity loves itself in us, and in itself, it sees and moves itself.”

John diverges from the Aristotelians by rejecting the real existence of individual things, preferring to call Plato the pillar of philosophers. Nonetheless, the first three of his modes of being are indirectly derived from Aristotle’s categories of the unmoved mover, the moved and moving, and the movable but not moved. The fourth mode of being in John’s system—that which is neither creating nor created—is drawn from the teaching of Pseudo-Dionysius the Areopagite on the return of all things to God.

From this brief summary, the unorthodox nature of the views of John Scotus Eriugena becomes clear. His pantheism, which denies the independent substantial reality of creation, contradicts Christian doctrine. No prudent theologian could accept his interpretation of the process of creation from “nothing.” In his conception of the Trinity, which bears a strong resemblance to the thought of Plotinus, the three hypostases appear unequal, though John strives to shield himself from criticism on this point. All these heretical views testify to his remarkable independence of thought in the ninth century. It is possible that the Neoplatonist character of his teachings was a common phenomenon in Ireland, much as it had been among the Greek Church Fathers of the fourth and fifth centuries. Had we more complete information about the development of Irish Christianity from the fifth to the ninth century, John might not seem such an astonishing anomaly. Alternatively, many of the heretical elements in his work may be attributed to the influence of Pseudo-Dionysius the Areopagite, who, due to his supposed connection with St. Paul, was mistakenly regarded as an orthodox thinker.

John’s perspective on creation as a process without a beginning in time is inherently heretical, compelling him to treat the history of creation in the Book of Genesis as an allegory. Consequently, Paradise and the Fall of man cannot be understood in a literal sense. Like many pantheists, John struggles with the problem of sin. He claims that man was initially unaware of sin, and in this state, there was no division of the sexes. This, of course, contradicts the scriptural account: “He created them male and female.” According to John, sin was the sole reason for the division of humanity into men and women, with the woman embodying the sensual and fallen nature of the species. Ultimately, he argues, the distinction of sexes will vanish, and we shall possess purely spiritual bodies. Sin consists in a malice of will—a false attribution of goodness to what is not good. This sin is punished naturally through the exposure of the vanity of sinful desires. However, such punishment is not eternal; like Origen, John asserts that even the devils will eventually be saved, albeit after other humans.

The translation of Pseudo-Dionysius the Areopagite, carried out by John, greatly influenced the development of medieval thought; in contrast, his magnum opus, On the Division of Nature (Periphyseon), had a minimal impact. This work was repeatedly condemned as heretical, and in 1225, Pope Honorius III finally ordered all copies to be burned. Fortunately, this order was not executed with due diligence.





Über den Autor

Dieser Artikel wurde von Sykalo Yevhen zusammengestellt und redigiert — Bildungsplattform-Manager mit über 12 Jahren Erfahrung in der Entwicklung methodischer Online-Projekte im Bereich Philosophie und Geisteswissenschaften.

Quellen und Methodik

Der Inhalt basiert auf akademischen Quellen in mehreren Sprachen — darunter ukrainische, russische und englische Universitätslehrbücher sowie wissenschaftliche Ausgaben zur Geschichte der Philosophie. Die Texte wurden aus den Originalquellen ins Deutsche übertragen und redaktionell bearbeitet. Alle Artikel werden vor der Veröffentlichung inhaltlich und didaktisch geprüft.

Zuletzt geändert: 15/11/2026