Philosophy and Religion - The Task of Philosophy - The Task and System of Philosophy
Introduction to philosophy based on a historical approach - 2024 Inhalt

The Task and System of Philosophy

The Task of Philosophy

Philosophy and Religion

The relationship between philosophy and religion changes continually in accordance with evolving historical conditions. Yet this relationship has always exhibited a dual nature: it can be either friendly or hostile, generating a struggle between worldviews that has caused discord in philosophy from its inception. The history of philosophy thus serves not merely as a mirror reflecting scientific development, but primarily as a battleground for the religious convictions that have stirred humanity across the ages. By transferring this struggle into the sphere of scientific inquiry, philosophy assumes a cultural mission: to instill scientific perspectives within religious contexts. In this way, science participates in the evolution of religious worldviews largely through philosophy. The relationship between philosophy and religion consequently encompasses various aspects that, while shifting over time, significantly shape the character of philosophy itself.

In Greek philosophy, opposition to the polytheism of popular religion emerges as a distinctive characteristic. This opposition often surpasses the scientific aspirations of philosophers. Philosophy stands from early on as a champion of monotheistic perspectives. In the teachings of Plato and Aristotle, this struggle reaches its pinnacle, intertwining religious and scientific worldviews into a unity where the ultimate principles of scientific understanding also serve as the foundation for religious thought. This aspiration evolves in subsequent stages of Greek philosophy, particularly among the Stoics and Epicureans. Here, partly due to the decline of popular religion, the emphasis shifts from merely reforming religious beliefs to replacing them with philosophy. Yet this shift does not alter the one-sided nature of the relationship, as philosophy continues to exert its influence on religion rather than vice versa. It is only during the decline of ancient philosophy, influenced by nascent Christian ideas that liberated forces opposing pagan philosophy, that the situation begins to change. Gradually, religion acquires a dominant role, and philosophy becomes its servant. Even proponents of ancient philosophy who sought to counter the rising Christian worldview by restoring ancient belief in the gods through philosophical and symbolic interpretations were swept up in the same movement that marked the emerging Christian philosophy of the Middle Ages.

In this lengthy second period, the relationship between philosophy and religion reverses the dynamic that existed during the flourishing of ancient philosophy: the religious worldview entirely subjugates philosophy. Although philosophy and the concepts it developed in antiquity could influence the evolution of dogmas, philosophy found itself, as the servant of theology, directed by unchanging Christian beliefs. It merely provided those beliefs with a specific scientific formulation. This relationship initially provoked no disagreement, save for contention over how philosophy could serve as an auxiliary science to religion. Gradually, however, this disagreement morphed into a conflict of opinions that drove the ultimate liberation of philosophy from the dominion of theology. The question that introduced discord into the scholarly world at the end of the Middle Ages was whether philosophy could serve faith at all, or if faith should remain self-enclosed. Scholars also debated whether philosophy could at least provide a complete understanding of the sensory world. Even during the decline of medieval philosophy, the attention of thinkers increasingly gravitated toward resolving the latter alternative, securing the free status that philosophy has occupied since the dawn of modernity.

Yet this does not definitively settle the relationship between religion and philosophy. As modern philosophy absorbs all past philosophical currents, the struggle between worldviews assumes a more intense character than before. Greater freedom in philosophical thought expands the arena of contention. Initially, alongside the separation of the domains of philosophy and religion achieved at the end of the Middle Ages, a perspective emerged wherein philosophy encompasses the entirety of secular knowledge while religion serves as the norm to which science should adhere. Philosophy is therefore pure science. Nevertheless, because faith holds greater value than knowledge, philosophy must yield to dogma in all questionable instances. This subordination, however, often proved to be a conditional formulation, primarily in Catholic countries, devised to prevent potential ecclesiastical opposition to proposed doctrines. From this context, during the Enlightenment, an understanding gradually developed that stands in stark contrast to the original. It is not philosophy that must submit to the control of dogma, but dogma that must be subjected to philosophical inquiry. Thus arises the demand for a religion of pure reason to replace traditional positive religion, aspiring to possess a universal rather than a particular character. It essentially represents a universally significant system of belief, much like philosophy, viewed as a science, claims to be a universally significant system of knowledge. Furthermore, within the philosophical system, religion is subordinated to science, implying that the content of faith can encompass only what also constitutes an object of knowledge. In the most extreme philosophical systems of this period, the distinction between religious and scientific worldviews is dismissed altogether, and the content of faith is ultimately reduced to a defined set of scientific laws concerning the foundations of existence, derived either empirically or speculatively.

However, this understanding undergoes a significant transformation in the period of modern philosophy following the Enlightenment, primarily associated with the name of Kant. Kant demonstrated that religious worldviews rest not on concepts that could be delineated by known logical and empirical criteria, as scientific concepts can be, but on transcendental presuppositions that can never constitute the content of pure science, instead relying directly on certain boundary concepts that remain inaccessible to scientific cognition, thus holding regulatory significance for it. Consequently, religion and philosophy become distinct and independent domains, each complementing the other only to the extent that the sensory world presupposes the supersensory. This is further revealed by the fact that scientific problems ultimately lead to transcendental questions concerning the ultimate foundation and purpose of things—questions that are posed by science but cannot be resolved by it.

From this relationship, it primarily follows that philosophy and religion must mutually acknowledge their independence and the distinct nature of their respective tasks. Consequently, the further development of the new philosophy, which finds its starting point in Kant, is directed in sharp opposition to the philosophy of the preceding era, although a return to past tendencies often persists to the present day. Philosophy, like any other science, deals with the empirical sensory world, which is the sole object of our knowledge. Philosophy neither wishes nor can be anything other than the final link in the chain of theoretical sciences. The subject of religion, on the other hand, pertains to the supersensory domain, which, although it may be an object of human desires and hopes, remains inaccessible to theoretical knowledge. Nevertheless, the empirical sensory world inevitably points towards it. This happens because the quest to find the foundation and purpose of things does not halt where our knowledge encounters definite boundaries, but, due to the unique nature of our reason, transcends those boundaries. Since both domains are entirely distinct in their content, philosophy can set no defined limits to religious worldviews. Just as religion is neither authorized nor capable of intervening in the affairs of science, be it philosophy or any other specialized discipline, so it follows. Therefore, just as religion is entirely unconcerned with questions such as whether the Earth moves in cosmic space, whether humans descended from apes, or whether psychological phenomena necessitate the assumption that the soul is a substance, so too does philosophy have nothing to do with how humans, in their religious needs, relate to the supersensory world that complements their sensory experience.

Yet the relationship between religion and philosophy cannot be reduced to a simple opposition. The knowing and the believing subject, much like the philosophizing and the religious individual, are not two separate personalities locked in internal isolation. Instead, human reason persistently strives for unity, a drive that tolerates no unresolved contradictions across different branches of knowledge. Nineteenth-century philosophy sought to satisfy this demand through two distinct religious-philosophical systems. These systems built upon Kant’s principle of the mutual autonomy of religion and philosophy, even as they opposed contemporary movements that aimed to absorb religion entirely into philosophy. The first attempt treated the sensory and supersensory worlds as the objects of two distinct spiritual functions. Reason governs the sensory world according to its innate laws. Feeling claims the supersensory world, confining its proper sphere to an immediate intuition of humanity’s relationship to a supersensory foundation—a relationship that manifests in religion as absolute dependence. Schleiermacher stands as the chief advocate of this dualistic interpretation of Kant. The second attempt viewed religion and philosophy as equally necessary products of the human mind. Neither possesses an exclusive content of its own; both serve merely as different forms through which universal reason reveals itself within individual consciousness. Religion operates symbolically through feeling and representation, employing imagination as its organ. Philosophy develops logically through thought, employing the thinking mind as its organ. Thus, philosophy and religion share the same essential content, differing only in the medium of their expression. Hegel remains the principal representative of this monistic transformation of Kantian thought.

Although these attempts to reconcile religion and philosophy still find adherents today, mainstream currents in both fields have largely moved beyond them. They have instead returned to a broader and more open-ended Kantian conception of the relationship between faith and thought. Modern theology has driven this return. Striving to establish itself as a true science, theology seeks to mediate between philosophy and religion, functioning as an auxiliary science that prepares the ground for philosophical inquiry. Consequently, philosophy does not take immediate experience as its raw material, but rather knowledge already organized by the specialized sciences. As a critical history of religious traditions and texts, theology belongs to the historical and philological disciplines. Yet because it investigates the psychological origins and ethical significance of religious ideas, it also intersects closely with psychology and ethics. Philosophy approaches theology just as it approaches any other specialized discipline: it seeks to synthesize the principles and methods of these fields into a coherent system. Religion therefore does not furnish the immediate content of philosophical inquiry, any more than mathematical, physical, or historical problems do. Instead, philosophy examines facts that have already undergone scientific treatment, drawing on both the psychological and historical branches of religious science. The philosophy of religion relates to positive religion in the exact same way that the philosophy of law relates to positive law, or aesthetics relates to the history of art. In every such case, the subject of philosophy is material already processed by a specialized science. When philosophy turns to any domain of human life, it addresses not the raw experience itself, but the systematic results of its analysis. Scientific findings regarding religion become philosophical objects precisely where specialized inquiry reaches its limits. Philosophy begins where the methods and conclusions of one specialized field intersect with those of another, ultimately confronting the overarching transcendental presuppositions of human knowledge.

If we compare the historical relationship between philosophy and religion with the relationship established between philosophy and the entirety of other specialized sciences, we see that no fundamental difference remains. Consequently, the science of religion fully integrates into the corpus of other sciences. Philosophy can no more establish new religions than it can create positive law or achieve discoveries in the natural sciences or psychology. Its task here also consists in investigating the content of data already processed by specialized science and integrating them into the general system of our knowledge. This task is inherently theoretical, and it becomes practical only indirectly through the influence of theoretical knowledge on human activity. Nevertheless, in striving to influence practical activity, the foremost role belongs to the specialized science that unites practical inclinations with theoretical ones—namely, theology. Just as in the domain of law, the primary influence on positive law belongs to legal science, and only indirectly, through its mediation, to the philosophy of law.

Initially unequal, the relationships between philosophy and science on the one hand, and philosophy and religion on the other, gradually transform with changing cultural conditions until they become identical. Thus, the relationship of philosophy to other sciences also encompasses its relationship to religion.

The general definition of philosophy as a universal science requires no supplementation to express its relationship to religion. It merely needs the clarification that the specialized sciences forming the foundation of philosophy must also include the science of religion in its entirety, provided that it functions as an independent theoretical science. This final qualification is always useful to append. Theology—more so than any other specialized science—stands in close relation to practical life. It is simultaneously defined by practical aspirations that often have little in common with scientific aims and frequently obstruct scientific inquiry.





Über den Autor

Dieser Artikel wurde von Sykalo Yevhen zusammengestellt und redigiert — Bildungsplattform-Manager mit über 12 Jahren Erfahrung in der Entwicklung methodischer Online-Projekte im Bereich Philosophie und Geisteswissenschaften.

Quellen und Methodik

Der Inhalt basiert auf akademischen Quellen in mehreren Sprachen — darunter ukrainische, russische und englische Universitätslehrbücher sowie wissenschaftliche Ausgaben zur Geschichte der Philosophie. Die Texte wurden aus den Originalquellen ins Deutsche übertragen und redaktionell bearbeitet. Alle Artikel werden vor der Veröffentlichung inhaltlich und didaktisch geprüft.

Zuletzt geändert: 15/11/2026